The following was written by Pete Sarafian and appeared in the SWAP (Small Wilderness Area Preservation) news bulletin. Pete is the Chief Weed Warrior, a group of volunteers who toil in the Elfin Forest in Los Osos, keeping non-native invasives at bay. Now, alas, thanks to lazy, careless people, invasive weeds threatening the unique Elfin preserve are being joined by dog poop. I thought this post would be a break from the Endless Sewer Wars, but, it's not: Poop is poop, canine or human. And un-picked up poop contributes to street run-off into the Bay. Pet Poop
Proliferates
by Pete Sarafian, SWAP Conservation Chair
Sandra Beebe of Morro Bay has worked tirelessly to obtain funds for mutt mitt dispensers and bags. She single-handedly initiated the Small Wilderness Area Preservation (SWAP) program in the Elfin Forest to responsibly dispose of pet poop. There now is a dispenser and garbage bag at every one of the seven street entrances to the Forest. What could be more convenient for pet owners? Unfortunately, not everyone in Los Osos and the surrounding area has responded as a responsible citizen and good pet owner. Lately, it has seemed as though locals have taken increased pride in leaving unsightly, smelly, polluting poop around the Forest. This irresponsible behavior does great harm in polluting Morro Bay with fecal matter and causing high bacteria counts. Pet poop even is implicated in the die-off of sea otters along our coast.
Recently SWAP went out in the Forest on two separate occasions about a month apart and gathered up the disgusting dog doo. Over a one-month period, there was an accumulation of nearly five gallons of canine crap. This disgusting task yielded about 20 pounds of dried bowser b.m. At this rate, about a half-ton of turds are deposited in the Elfin Forest each year. That’s 1,000 pounds, folks. The community cannot sustain this kind of pollution without serious environmental consequences. Please remind your dog-owning neighbors to pick up their fido fecals.
Monday, April 17, 2006
Sunday, April 16, 2006
Measure B Bites Dust? Perils of Overreach? Does it Matter? Questions Remain!
Judge Piquet [correction! correction! It was Judge Martin Tangeman's case. Here in Sewerville, you need a program to keep all the lawsuits straight. My apologies.] handed down his ruling as to the validity of the Measure B initiative, an initiative that would have allowed the citizens to vote on selecting a sewer system they want to "buy," including the option of "none of the above." If I read his ruling right, it appears that the initiative failed because the initiative “over reached,” that is, it had a clause in it that allowed the voter to vote for NO PROJECT, an option that overstepped its bounds and slipped it into the realm of being an “administrative” decision, not strictly a” legislative” one.
What’s unclear to me is how the legal mandate (and limitations) of the Regional Water Quality Control Board fit within this ruling. The Board cannot dictate what kind of system is to be built. They can only set discharge standards, for example, and then approve or disapprove of whatever system is brought before them for a discharge permit.
So if voters elected a Board and the Board wanted to select one sort of system or another, the RWQCB would have no “administrative” say in the matter, only the right to approve or disapprove of whatever was decided. And if the voters elected a Board that decided they didn’t want to build ANY system and instead wanted to have the town’s tanks pumped every day and truck the wastewater to Oregon, the RWQCB would also have no say in using that method either, so long as the discharge requirements under Resolution 83-12 & 13 were met.
So, there’s my puzzle with this ruling. Tangeman ruled the measure invalid because, if I understand correctly, the initiative gave the voter power to directly vote for . . . something . . . as opposed to voting for elected officials who would then vote for . . . something. Apparently the former is “legislative” and is considered a no-no, while the latter is “administrative” and is o.k.
What I couldn’t find in the ruling is the judge’s discussion of a phrase that was in the Initiative that stated that if any section of the initiative was found to be illegal, it could be “severed” and the rest would remain. So, I have no idea what happened to that.
Also, it’s still a puzzle to me why the Judge had a problem with the clause in the initiative that allowed the voters to vote for NO PROJECT. He notes: “An initiative is not legally permitted to take over that administrative function by placing the issue of whether the District will comply with the state mandate in the hands of the electorate. Measure B unlawfully does so, by allowing the electorate to choose not only where such a facility shall be built, but whether such a facility will be built at all. In other words, the electorate is allowed to choose whether they prefer the “no project’ alternative, which means non-compliance with an existing state-imposed mandate.”
Uh, please correct me if I’m wrong, but doesn’t Resolution 83-12 & 13 set discharge levels, with an ultimate result in NO DISCHARGE by such and such time? And since the RWQCB can’t dictate WHAT system (if any) is to be built, (or where, if anywhere) I’m still puzzled as to why a NO PROJECT vote would violate anything, since the "state imposed mandate" is about discharge levels. Once again, if voters wanted to truck their waste daily to Oregon for disposal, they would be meeting the RWQCB’s discharge requirements (hence meeting the “state-imposed mandate”) but they’d be doing it without a “project.” So, I have to wonder if Judge Piquet thinks that the state and the Regional Board legally has an “administrative” say in building some particular project? So far as I know, they don’t. Not legally, at least. (Judge Tangeman) does note, “Although Resolution 83-13 did not specify how the discharge of sewage should be handled, it evidently contemplated the construction of some sort of facility because it established a timetable for the District to “Begin Design, Complete Design, obtain Construction Funding, Begin construction, Complete Construction.” What I’d be curious to know is whether that “evident” contemplation was mere assumption or had some legal basis.)
And, finally, does any of this matter any more? Seriously. For most folks, Measure B was a whisker-thin “win,” that, in may ways, simply represented a desperate measure on the part of people who wanted a say in where their sewer plant was going to be built since the recalled board refused to hold a Prop 218-type vote. (A matter that’s still unresolved.) So, now it’s kaput, does it matter?
As with all things Sewer, stay tuned.
Judge Piquet [correction! correction! It was Judge Martin Tangeman's case. Here in Sewerville, you need a program to keep all the lawsuits straight. My apologies.] handed down his ruling as to the validity of the Measure B initiative, an initiative that would have allowed the citizens to vote on selecting a sewer system they want to "buy," including the option of "none of the above." If I read his ruling right, it appears that the initiative failed because the initiative “over reached,” that is, it had a clause in it that allowed the voter to vote for NO PROJECT, an option that overstepped its bounds and slipped it into the realm of being an “administrative” decision, not strictly a” legislative” one.
What’s unclear to me is how the legal mandate (and limitations) of the Regional Water Quality Control Board fit within this ruling. The Board cannot dictate what kind of system is to be built. They can only set discharge standards, for example, and then approve or disapprove of whatever system is brought before them for a discharge permit.
So if voters elected a Board and the Board wanted to select one sort of system or another, the RWQCB would have no “administrative” say in the matter, only the right to approve or disapprove of whatever was decided. And if the voters elected a Board that decided they didn’t want to build ANY system and instead wanted to have the town’s tanks pumped every day and truck the wastewater to Oregon, the RWQCB would also have no say in using that method either, so long as the discharge requirements under Resolution 83-12 & 13 were met.
So, there’s my puzzle with this ruling. Tangeman ruled the measure invalid because, if I understand correctly, the initiative gave the voter power to directly vote for . . . something . . . as opposed to voting for elected officials who would then vote for . . . something. Apparently the former is “legislative” and is considered a no-no, while the latter is “administrative” and is o.k.
What I couldn’t find in the ruling is the judge’s discussion of a phrase that was in the Initiative that stated that if any section of the initiative was found to be illegal, it could be “severed” and the rest would remain. So, I have no idea what happened to that.
Also, it’s still a puzzle to me why the Judge had a problem with the clause in the initiative that allowed the voters to vote for NO PROJECT. He notes: “An initiative is not legally permitted to take over that administrative function by placing the issue of whether the District will comply with the state mandate in the hands of the electorate. Measure B unlawfully does so, by allowing the electorate to choose not only where such a facility shall be built, but whether such a facility will be built at all. In other words, the electorate is allowed to choose whether they prefer the “no project’ alternative, which means non-compliance with an existing state-imposed mandate.”
Uh, please correct me if I’m wrong, but doesn’t Resolution 83-12 & 13 set discharge levels, with an ultimate result in NO DISCHARGE by such and such time? And since the RWQCB can’t dictate WHAT system (if any) is to be built, (or where, if anywhere) I’m still puzzled as to why a NO PROJECT vote would violate anything, since the "state imposed mandate" is about discharge levels. Once again, if voters wanted to truck their waste daily to Oregon for disposal, they would be meeting the RWQCB’s discharge requirements (hence meeting the “state-imposed mandate”) but they’d be doing it without a “project.” So, I have to wonder if Judge Piquet thinks that the state and the Regional Board legally has an “administrative” say in building some particular project? So far as I know, they don’t. Not legally, at least. (Judge Tangeman) does note, “Although Resolution 83-13 did not specify how the discharge of sewage should be handled, it evidently contemplated the construction of some sort of facility because it established a timetable for the District to “Begin Design, Complete Design, obtain Construction Funding, Begin construction, Complete Construction.” What I’d be curious to know is whether that “evident” contemplation was mere assumption or had some legal basis.)
And, finally, does any of this matter any more? Seriously. For most folks, Measure B was a whisker-thin “win,” that, in may ways, simply represented a desperate measure on the part of people who wanted a say in where their sewer plant was going to be built since the recalled board refused to hold a Prop 218-type vote. (A matter that’s still unresolved.) So, now it’s kaput, does it matter?
As with all things Sewer, stay tuned.
Saturday, April 15, 2006
Ron Crawford over at http://www.sewerwatch.blogspot.com/ is asking another one of his annoying Koan-like questions as to just what the Regional Water Quality Control Board wad doing for two years while the first CSD futzed around on a “solution” that they had already ruled – prior to the CSD election – they wouldn’t support. Considering the RWQCB has access to a time machine – they’ve sent out official rulings of the CDO hearings BEFORE it’s even taken place – how cool is that? – so it seems to me they could hop into their Way Back Time Machine and set things right. Meanwhile, I was away for a few days during which time CSD President Lisa Schicker wrote a “Viewpoint” for the Tribune. In case anybody missed it, here it is. I find it particularly interesting that a local Superior Court judge, hearing I believe the measure B case (?? there are so many miscellaneous lawsuits, it’s hard to keep track of them all) stated in the courtroom “that the LOCSD board was ‘anti-sewer.’” Now, first of all, that’s an extraordinary statement of . . . bias? . . . to raise at the start of a hearing. But it’s also indicative of so much of the misinformation that’s out there in the community. And the unwillingness of even Superior Court judges to dig a little deeper than phony sound bites or misleading headlines. That this sort of misapprehension would appear from the bench should concern everyone in Los Osos. At any rate, here’s the “Viewpoint” piece.
Los Osos Board is NOT “Anti - Wastewater Project”
Viewpoint submitted to TT April 6, 2006 by Lisa Schicker, LOCSD President
Misconceptions about the Los Osos Board and their activities are rampant in SLO County and some clarifications are in order.
Last week, a SLO Superior Court Judge told his courtroom that the current LOCSD Board was "anti-sewer"; this was quite surprising. Contrary to this notion, our Board is actively working on a revised wastewater project, an environmentally preferred project that addresses affordability, sustainability and our groundwater recharge and saltwater intrusion problems.
We have NEVER been “anti”-clean water or “anti-wastewater project”, as many, including our esteemed judge, have been led to believe.
For health, safety, environmental and economical reasons, we stated repeatedly that any community treatment facility must be located away from the town-center, away from the library, church, schools, and National Estuary. We don’t believe it was sustainable or economical to truck sludge to Santa Barbara County at 80% water content; part of the old plan. The $50,000+ pricetag per household (or $205/month) wasn’t acceptable either, more expensive than anywhere in America.
The recall election seated three new “Move-the-Sewer” Directors in October– joining two already-seated “Move-the-Sewer” Directors. Many don’t know that the old board and manager ignored public pleas and drained the wastewater fund just before the election. This drawdown left the new board less than $100k to work with, not including unsold bonds or state revolving fund loan monies. The old board started construction less than 20 days before the election, putting their community at great financial risk.
Despite obvious legal and financial pressures, our Board is making progress on five promises: 1) increase public participation, 2) implement water conservation measures, 3) start a septic tank management program, 4) conduct affordability study and 5) deliver a holistic wastewater project to Los Osos ASAP.
Two different engineering companies were chosen for three of these tasks: a septic tank management plan and updated wastewater project report will be ready by summer’s end, both incorporate water conservation.
LOCSD Board passed Resolutions requesting assistance from Assemblyman Blakeslee and SLO County – asking them to encourage the water board to stop enforcement and work together instead on acceptable community solutions.
A LOCSD negotiating team meets regularly with Water Board staff, to establish dialogue, resolve issues and provide project updates.
Over thirty-five public meetings (taped and televised) were held since October 1. In addition to wastewater, LOCSD manages water, drainage, solid waste, lighting and emergency services - all on a shoestring annual budget of less than $3 million. Like all CSD’s, SLO County retains most of Los Osos’ property taxes.
Three monthly business meetings are held and 10 advisory/adhoc committees meet, increasing public participation.
On numerous occasions in 2003-2005, before and after we were elected, after writing and speaking against the flawed project at public meetings, various officials replied:
“If you don’t like the downtown project, then just change your Board”.
These words were spoken by several Regional and State Water Board members, County Supervisors and Coastal Commissioners.
That is what we did – we got elected and changed our Board. The question remains - will these same government agencies that encouraged us to “change our Board” recognize our commitment and work with us to change the project, as they promised?
Our Board is willing, able and determined to solve Los Osos problems – we request cooperation from other agencies to get the job done and we don’t want to spend any more of the people’s precious resources on defending against enforcement – this waste only takes us further from our common goals. We publicly invite SLO County, the Water Boards and our Assemblyman to join with us for all of Los Osos.
Lisa Schicker, President, LOCSD Board
Los Osos …………………………………………………………………………………….
Los Osos Board is NOT “Anti - Wastewater Project”
Viewpoint submitted to TT April 6, 2006 by Lisa Schicker, LOCSD President
Misconceptions about the Los Osos Board and their activities are rampant in SLO County and some clarifications are in order.
Last week, a SLO Superior Court Judge told his courtroom that the current LOCSD Board was "anti-sewer"; this was quite surprising. Contrary to this notion, our Board is actively working on a revised wastewater project, an environmentally preferred project that addresses affordability, sustainability and our groundwater recharge and saltwater intrusion problems.
We have NEVER been “anti”-clean water or “anti-wastewater project”, as many, including our esteemed judge, have been led to believe.
For health, safety, environmental and economical reasons, we stated repeatedly that any community treatment facility must be located away from the town-center, away from the library, church, schools, and National Estuary. We don’t believe it was sustainable or economical to truck sludge to Santa Barbara County at 80% water content; part of the old plan. The $50,000+ pricetag per household (or $205/month) wasn’t acceptable either, more expensive than anywhere in America.
The recall election seated three new “Move-the-Sewer” Directors in October– joining two already-seated “Move-the-Sewer” Directors. Many don’t know that the old board and manager ignored public pleas and drained the wastewater fund just before the election. This drawdown left the new board less than $100k to work with, not including unsold bonds or state revolving fund loan monies. The old board started construction less than 20 days before the election, putting their community at great financial risk.
Despite obvious legal and financial pressures, our Board is making progress on five promises: 1) increase public participation, 2) implement water conservation measures, 3) start a septic tank management program, 4) conduct affordability study and 5) deliver a holistic wastewater project to Los Osos ASAP.
Two different engineering companies were chosen for three of these tasks: a septic tank management plan and updated wastewater project report will be ready by summer’s end, both incorporate water conservation.
LOCSD Board passed Resolutions requesting assistance from Assemblyman Blakeslee and SLO County – asking them to encourage the water board to stop enforcement and work together instead on acceptable community solutions.
A LOCSD negotiating team meets regularly with Water Board staff, to establish dialogue, resolve issues and provide project updates.
Over thirty-five public meetings (taped and televised) were held since October 1. In addition to wastewater, LOCSD manages water, drainage, solid waste, lighting and emergency services - all on a shoestring annual budget of less than $3 million. Like all CSD’s, SLO County retains most of Los Osos’ property taxes.
Three monthly business meetings are held and 10 advisory/adhoc committees meet, increasing public participation.
On numerous occasions in 2003-2005, before and after we were elected, after writing and speaking against the flawed project at public meetings, various officials replied:
“If you don’t like the downtown project, then just change your Board”.
These words were spoken by several Regional and State Water Board members, County Supervisors and Coastal Commissioners.
That is what we did – we got elected and changed our Board. The question remains - will these same government agencies that encouraged us to “change our Board” recognize our commitment and work with us to change the project, as they promised?
Our Board is willing, able and determined to solve Los Osos problems – we request cooperation from other agencies to get the job done and we don’t want to spend any more of the people’s precious resources on defending against enforcement – this waste only takes us further from our common goals. We publicly invite SLO County, the Water Boards and our Assemblyman to join with us for all of Los Osos.
Lisa Schicker, President, LOCSD Board
Los Osos …………………………………………………………………………………….
Friday, April 14, 2006
Time Travel Hits Sewerville, Again.
First we had former General Manager Bruce Buel getting into his Waaaay Back Time Machine and zipping back to a nice day on the First of November a few years ago to sign a contract with Montgomery Watson Harza for millions of dollars worh of services even though he wouldn’t be hired by the CSD and legally authorized to sign those contract until November 14th.
For time travel fans, it was an exciting breakthrough. And now, it’s happened again. The Los Osos Forty-Five have received letters from Regional Water Quality Control Board CEO, Roger Briggs, dated April 28th describing the April 28th CDO Hearing and outlining the findings of the Board. Considering that the Los Osos 45 got these letters in the mail on April 11th – 13th, indicates that once again we've achieved . . . . TIME TRAVEL.
Miracles never cease here in Sewerville. Previous official letters from the RWQCB have stated that at the upcoming hearing on April 28, the Los Osos 45 will have a RIGHT to testify, call witnesses, present evidence, etc., so many of the 45 had been preparing their case, and were ready to do exactly that come April 28th. Now, they don’t need to. With the arrival of the official letter, they now know that, unbeknownst to them, they already had their “day in court.” Of course, it was a court that insists upon a Verdict First, with Evidence irrelevant, which, you must admit, saves so much more time than the other way around.
Of course, doing things this way opens one up to charges of being a Kangaroo Court, with cries of Sham! Sham! ringing thorough the air. Phooey. It’s not sham, it’s TIME TRAVEL . . . again!
On a happier note, for the first time in 30 years, remediation via a "pilot" onsite enhanced septic system in the form of the Piranha system was installed at the CSD’s fire house. (Another bype of onsite technology is being proposed for use at the LOCSD Water Yard) Lysimeters were installed under the firehouse leach field and testing can commence. Even the RWQCB, which has disallowed any onsite systems within the prohibition zone, some time ago gave permission to the “old CSD Board” if they wanted to install a “test” unit outside the Prohibition Zone (apparently the letter wasn’t made public until recently “discovered” by the new staff and board.) Why that becomes interesting is because it’s clear that should they have wished to do so, the county, the original CSD Board and the Regional Water Quality Control Board (which in resolution 83-12, gave the authority to both the county and CSD) could have been doing a variety of enhanced onsite remediations with their septic systems all the years and years that the various sewer projects were being considered and rejected and the Sewer Wars raged on. Indeed, various factions within the community have begged for years for the creation of a Septic Maintenance District that would have allowed for such improvements to the groundwater. Everyone, including the Regional Water Quality Control Board, refused to do zip, which makes their present hang-wringing declaration that Los Osos is in some sort of septic crisis requiring this mad CDO pumping scheme even more hypocritical than usual.
Now, with the installation of the Piranha system, even the RWQCB is expressing an interest in the test data that will be forthcoming. (I know, why don’t they just get in their time machine and zip forwards a few months for a look-see?)
Dr. Daniel Wickham, developer of the Pirana system, owner of “SludgeHammer” systems, spoke at the CSD April 13th meeting and noted a curious fact: Every single industry has developed and uses bio-remediation in controlling and dealing with its various “wastes,” except sanitation entities. A county’s multi-gazillion dollar a year wine industry, for example, will be a leader in developing and using onsite bio-remediation for its waste, while the same county’s sanitation district will still be limping along with old systems, with no attempt to deliberately control and manipulate the “product” using 21st century technologies. This results in out-dated sewage systems that are breaking and leaking and polluting and sludge-generating and costing taxpayers a bundle, aided and abetted and made worse by a lazy regulatory mind-set that’s still willfully stuck in the 19th century.
More Sewerville Notes: It was noted in last night’s CSD meeting that thanks to the disclosure laws on campaign donations, it’s now known that during the recall campaign, Montgomery Watson Harza and Barnard Construction donated $10,000 each to the “Save the Dream Coalition” to oppose the recall. Those were folks who designed and were starting to build the Tri-W sewer plant, which plans were directly threatened by the recall.
Twenty-thousand smackaroonies to be repaid from the citizens’ sewer rates, all just a part of doing business in Sewerville. God bless the child... . .
First we had former General Manager Bruce Buel getting into his Waaaay Back Time Machine and zipping back to a nice day on the First of November a few years ago to sign a contract with Montgomery Watson Harza for millions of dollars worh of services even though he wouldn’t be hired by the CSD and legally authorized to sign those contract until November 14th.
For time travel fans, it was an exciting breakthrough. And now, it’s happened again. The Los Osos Forty-Five have received letters from Regional Water Quality Control Board CEO, Roger Briggs, dated April 28th describing the April 28th CDO Hearing and outlining the findings of the Board. Considering that the Los Osos 45 got these letters in the mail on April 11th – 13th, indicates that once again we've achieved . . . . TIME TRAVEL.
Miracles never cease here in Sewerville. Previous official letters from the RWQCB have stated that at the upcoming hearing on April 28, the Los Osos 45 will have a RIGHT to testify, call witnesses, present evidence, etc., so many of the 45 had been preparing their case, and were ready to do exactly that come April 28th. Now, they don’t need to. With the arrival of the official letter, they now know that, unbeknownst to them, they already had their “day in court.” Of course, it was a court that insists upon a Verdict First, with Evidence irrelevant, which, you must admit, saves so much more time than the other way around.
Of course, doing things this way opens one up to charges of being a Kangaroo Court, with cries of Sham! Sham! ringing thorough the air. Phooey. It’s not sham, it’s TIME TRAVEL . . . again!
On a happier note, for the first time in 30 years, remediation via a "pilot" onsite enhanced septic system in the form of the Piranha system was installed at the CSD’s fire house. (Another bype of onsite technology is being proposed for use at the LOCSD Water Yard) Lysimeters were installed under the firehouse leach field and testing can commence. Even the RWQCB, which has disallowed any onsite systems within the prohibition zone, some time ago gave permission to the “old CSD Board” if they wanted to install a “test” unit outside the Prohibition Zone (apparently the letter wasn’t made public until recently “discovered” by the new staff and board.) Why that becomes interesting is because it’s clear that should they have wished to do so, the county, the original CSD Board and the Regional Water Quality Control Board (which in resolution 83-12, gave the authority to both the county and CSD) could have been doing a variety of enhanced onsite remediations with their septic systems all the years and years that the various sewer projects were being considered and rejected and the Sewer Wars raged on. Indeed, various factions within the community have begged for years for the creation of a Septic Maintenance District that would have allowed for such improvements to the groundwater. Everyone, including the Regional Water Quality Control Board, refused to do zip, which makes their present hang-wringing declaration that Los Osos is in some sort of septic crisis requiring this mad CDO pumping scheme even more hypocritical than usual.
Now, with the installation of the Piranha system, even the RWQCB is expressing an interest in the test data that will be forthcoming. (I know, why don’t they just get in their time machine and zip forwards a few months for a look-see?)
Dr. Daniel Wickham, developer of the Pirana system, owner of “SludgeHammer” systems, spoke at the CSD April 13th meeting and noted a curious fact: Every single industry has developed and uses bio-remediation in controlling and dealing with its various “wastes,” except sanitation entities. A county’s multi-gazillion dollar a year wine industry, for example, will be a leader in developing and using onsite bio-remediation for its waste, while the same county’s sanitation district will still be limping along with old systems, with no attempt to deliberately control and manipulate the “product” using 21st century technologies. This results in out-dated sewage systems that are breaking and leaking and polluting and sludge-generating and costing taxpayers a bundle, aided and abetted and made worse by a lazy regulatory mind-set that’s still willfully stuck in the 19th century.
More Sewerville Notes: It was noted in last night’s CSD meeting that thanks to the disclosure laws on campaign donations, it’s now known that during the recall campaign, Montgomery Watson Harza and Barnard Construction donated $10,000 each to the “Save the Dream Coalition” to oppose the recall. Those were folks who designed and were starting to build the Tri-W sewer plant, which plans were directly threatened by the recall.
Twenty-thousand smackaroonies to be repaid from the citizens’ sewer rates, all just a part of doing business in Sewerville. God bless the child... . .
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)