Call Mr. Shallcross. The Anti-Sewerite Los Osos CSD is Borrowing Money From Themselves To Move The Sewer Project Forward! Stop them! Haven’t They Been Listening To Mr. Shallcross and the RWQCB? We Los Ososians are all anti-sewer!
Yep, getting bizarre out there. Judge Piquet has frozen the district’s assets until an audit can be completed. Fair enough. (The various breach of contract lawsuits will probably turn into some version of Charles Dicken’s Bleak House, and the CSD will remain mired in The Courts of Chancery for generations!) The RWQCB claims they’re vitally interested in getting a sewer project built and so has slapped CDOs on the community, a move that does absolutely nothing to get a sewer project built, but instead drains away resources, time, money, community focus. The CDOs are presently on hold while the RWQCB sorts through a raft of “unintended consequences” deriving from their ill-considered, hasty actions. . A group calling themselves Taxpayers Watch claims, among other things, that the CSD is wasting money on too many legal bills, so it sues the district, thereby – yes, you guessed it -- causing them to spend even more money on legal bills. That same group has spearheaded a Dissolve the CSD movement, implying that if the county takes over Los Osos, everyone will be safe from the furies of the RWQCB’s CDO. (False, they won’t be, according to the RWQCB’s own official statements.) And further implying that the county will simply step in and Poof! Tri-W will magically appear in the giant hole in the ground and Los Osos will once again have a sewer plant in the middle of town and all will be well. All this implication going on, yet there’s no indication from the county that it wants its red-haired step child back, trailing all it’s woes and lawsuits and liabilities. And no indication that county engineering would even sign off on a re-started Tri W and no indication that any new State Revolving Fund Loan could be used since the new rules applying to any new loans require that wastewater treatment plants be “sustainable” and Tri W never was, so who knows how that would play out . . . . in court . . . . again, thereby delaying any treatment plant moving ahead for years. Is this all getting too deja vuish for you?
And now, the Tribune headline, “For sewer funds, Osos looks to itself.” WHAAAAATTTT? Why, what a novel idea. You mean Los Osos can get off the pot, so to speak, borrow money from “its water fund and solid-waste fund” to move ahead with the sewer project update, the amended EIR, the siting search, a Prop 218-type vote, and so forth, then vote to form some type of Septic Management District on its own (to start a variety of discharge mitigations, if nothing else), and do it all by either “using revenue generated from an as-yet-undeveloped community-wide septic tank management plan,” or sell revenue bonds, or get federal funding or -- why, here’s an absolutely novel thought – property owners in the prohibition zone could actually vote to tax themselves a modest amount now to move the sewer project forward while various alphabet soup agencies battle on and everyone else stays mired in the ditch, wrestling lawyers, for years.
Oh, wait, I must have fallen asleep and been dreaming to even suggest that last bit there. I mean, prohibition zone folks stepping up to declare that an utter failure of government and government agencies has clearly taken place, so now they’re gonna go move ahead on their own? Look to themselves for a way forward? All those anti-sewer folk out there in Los Osos that Mr. Shallcross wants to sing Kumbaya?
Now I know I was dreaming.
Saturday, May 06, 2006
Oh, Please, Pleeezzzeee, Dear God, Stop Them Before They Shoot Again!
Brief notice in the Tribune that the Los Osos 45 who were scheduled to proceed with the Mad Hatter’s Tea Party CDO Hearings on the 11th and 12 will have the hearings postposed until further notice. Seems the delay is “because of a request from the water board’s prosecutors, who will be changing legal counsel.”
In Jeffrey Young’s official notice, it notes the “Prosecution Team requested a continuance to accommodate a change in its legal counsel (see posting at: http://www.swrcb.ca.gov/rwqcb3/Los%20osos/Index.htm).” It also notes that at the May 11 hearing, beginning at 10:00 a.m., there will be a discussion item only. “Discussion will be allowed regarding procedural issues only, such as when to conduct subsequent proceedings. The Water Board WILL NOT hear testimony, cross examination or public comments regarding the proposed Cease and Desist Orders on May 11, 20066.” The board won’t take any substantive action either and when they figure out when they’ll proceed, they’ll post the date.
During the April 28 hearing, the CSD’s attorney, Steve Onstot, requested the hearing be postponed until brand new “prosecutors” could be found to try the case. He cited a recent ruling (Morongo Band of Mission Indians vs State Water Resources Control Board, Super. ct. Sacramento county 2006, No. 04C500535) , a case that found “inherent bias” in the way the RWQCB conducts it’s legal hearings and civil liability actions & etc.
Basically, the case went to “inherent bias” on the part of Regional Board members (i.e. the “judges” in any hearing) who regularly consulted with, had closed session meetings with, did “regular Board business” with the same folks who then would make up the “prosecution” team for any formal civil “trial/hearing.”
This is akin (in the real world) to a judge who regularly meets with the staff of the DA’s office, consults on other cases with them, discusses closed session strategy on many others issues and policies with them, THEN, when the same DA’s come before his bench to prosecute a particular case, suddenly claims that he’s fair and neutral and has no bias towards the prosecution team. A court said, Nuh-huh, the CSD’s attorney’s request to postpone was slapped down by RWQCB Chairman Young, who rather acidly noted that until it’s settled case law (the Morongo case can still be appealed and reviewed and reversed) it doesn’t really exist and so has no standing and the CDO hearings will go forward – but he would note the objection for the record.
Now, someone must have re-read the case and the case law it’s base on and figured – for prudence sake, if nothing else – to wait until they can assemble a brand-new “prosecution team.” I also would have to wonder what impact that particular Morongo case will have on all the other cases the various Regional Boards are presently involved in. And what impact any final ruling may have on past cases?
In the meantime, Do you suppose it would be too much to ask that maybe, if Los Osos finally get’s lucky, that a new prosecution team would arrive sans the baggage of the old team? Sans Briggs’ baggage, sans the “bad blood,” sans the refusal to deal with their own failed enforcement history and culpability in creating this train-wreck, sans all the “bad science,” sans, in short, everything that’s kept cooler heads from stepping back and negotiating a smarter way forward than CDO’s?
One of the hallmarks of great litigators is they hate Pyrrhic victories because they know how profoundly stupid and wasteful they are. Great litigators know how to win by cutting practical win-win, smart-win “deals” before they ever see the inside of a courtroom.
If Los Osos gets lucky, a really smart litigation team will arrive, sans all the baggage that keeps the present “prosecution” team blinded and stumbling, and will ask themselves some questions: What are the RWQCB and the LOCSD really trying to accomplish here? Are individual CDO’s the proper tool to get that done? What’s the difference between “cooperative dischargers” and “recalcitrant dischargers?” Are there several other regulatory ways to skin this cat that would be more cost effective and environmentally better than simply plodding blindly forward with some poorly thought-out scheme until everyone ends up in court thereby wasting gazillions of tax dollars while running the chance that, in the real world, somebody, including the RWQCB, may lose their case on some cockamamie minor procedural goof-up and the whole stupid game will have to start all over again?
Is that too much to ask for. Pleeeeze God? Well, as with all things Sewerish, stay tuned.
Brief notice in the Tribune that the Los Osos 45 who were scheduled to proceed with the Mad Hatter’s Tea Party CDO Hearings on the 11th and 12 will have the hearings postposed until further notice. Seems the delay is “because of a request from the water board’s prosecutors, who will be changing legal counsel.”
In Jeffrey Young’s official notice, it notes the “Prosecution Team requested a continuance to accommodate a change in its legal counsel (see posting at: http://www.swrcb.ca.gov/rwqcb3/Los%20osos/Index.htm).” It also notes that at the May 11 hearing, beginning at 10:00 a.m., there will be a discussion item only. “Discussion will be allowed regarding procedural issues only, such as when to conduct subsequent proceedings. The Water Board WILL NOT hear testimony, cross examination or public comments regarding the proposed Cease and Desist Orders on May 11, 20066.” The board won’t take any substantive action either and when they figure out when they’ll proceed, they’ll post the date.
During the April 28 hearing, the CSD’s attorney, Steve Onstot, requested the hearing be postponed until brand new “prosecutors” could be found to try the case. He cited a recent ruling (Morongo Band of Mission Indians vs State Water Resources Control Board, Super. ct. Sacramento county 2006, No. 04C500535) , a case that found “inherent bias” in the way the RWQCB conducts it’s legal hearings and civil liability actions & etc.
Basically, the case went to “inherent bias” on the part of Regional Board members (i.e. the “judges” in any hearing) who regularly consulted with, had closed session meetings with, did “regular Board business” with the same folks who then would make up the “prosecution” team for any formal civil “trial/hearing.”
This is akin (in the real world) to a judge who regularly meets with the staff of the DA’s office, consults on other cases with them, discusses closed session strategy on many others issues and policies with them, THEN, when the same DA’s come before his bench to prosecute a particular case, suddenly claims that he’s fair and neutral and has no bias towards the prosecution team. A court said, Nuh-huh, the CSD’s attorney’s request to postpone was slapped down by RWQCB Chairman Young, who rather acidly noted that until it’s settled case law (the Morongo case can still be appealed and reviewed and reversed) it doesn’t really exist and so has no standing and the CDO hearings will go forward – but he would note the objection for the record.
Now, someone must have re-read the case and the case law it’s base on and figured – for prudence sake, if nothing else – to wait until they can assemble a brand-new “prosecution team.” I also would have to wonder what impact that particular Morongo case will have on all the other cases the various Regional Boards are presently involved in. And what impact any final ruling may have on past cases?
In the meantime, Do you suppose it would be too much to ask that maybe, if Los Osos finally get’s lucky, that a new prosecution team would arrive sans the baggage of the old team? Sans Briggs’ baggage, sans the “bad blood,” sans the refusal to deal with their own failed enforcement history and culpability in creating this train-wreck, sans all the “bad science,” sans, in short, everything that’s kept cooler heads from stepping back and negotiating a smarter way forward than CDO’s?
One of the hallmarks of great litigators is they hate Pyrrhic victories because they know how profoundly stupid and wasteful they are. Great litigators know how to win by cutting practical win-win, smart-win “deals” before they ever see the inside of a courtroom.
If Los Osos gets lucky, a really smart litigation team will arrive, sans all the baggage that keeps the present “prosecution” team blinded and stumbling, and will ask themselves some questions: What are the RWQCB and the LOCSD really trying to accomplish here? Are individual CDO’s the proper tool to get that done? What’s the difference between “cooperative dischargers” and “recalcitrant dischargers?” Are there several other regulatory ways to skin this cat that would be more cost effective and environmentally better than simply plodding blindly forward with some poorly thought-out scheme until everyone ends up in court thereby wasting gazillions of tax dollars while running the chance that, in the real world, somebody, including the RWQCB, may lose their case on some cockamamie minor procedural goof-up and the whole stupid game will have to start all over again?
Is that too much to ask for. Pleeeeze God? Well, as with all things Sewerish, stay tuned.
Friday, May 05, 2006
Ron Crawford over at Sewerwatch (www.sewerwatch.blogspot.com) checks in again, taking aim at one of his favorite targets, the Tribune. Duck and cover.
Thursday, May 04, 2006
Letters, we got more letters . . .
The following letter was sent to the Tribune from the husband of the letter previously posted. He also spent 12 hours at the April 28th hearing and took issue with how the Tribune covered the story the next day. His letter is followed by a reply from the Tribune. Both Moylan’s letters and the reply are extremely instructive if you want to see how a story can be slanted, how headlines can be manipulated (written by somebody who wasn't even there) while all the time denying that any of those techniques are at work. Most interesting is the tactic of suggesting that a “remedy” for what may well be plain old bad reporting is to be had by writing an “opinion” viewpoint which may be printed in the editorial/”opinion” page, thereby clueing the reader in that this is merely “opinion,” while what appeared in the original story is “fact.” If you were at the meeting for 12 hours and/or watched the whole thing on Channel 20, and read the original Tribune story, I invite you to read these letters and reply and see if you understand what the Moylans are objecting to. To me, it’s a familiar complaint when it comes to Los Osos Sewer Reporting.[printed with permission of the Moylans]
April 29, 2006
Dear Chip Visci, Matt Lazier, and Nathan Welton,
Your front page article about the RWQCB hearing was slanted, untrue in parts and lacked ethical integrity.
The title on your front page, “Los Osos raises a ruckus at hearing with water officials,” suggested that there was a commotion or disturbance throughout the hearing. This was not the case. I attended the hearing for the complete 12 ½ hours. The general tone of the hearing was one of a very interested and concerned populace at a controversial meeting. Voices were raised perhaps 4 or 5 times during the entire 12 ½ hours.
The first sentence of your article stated, “Tempers flared for 12 hours…” This is patently untrue. A few people were upset and spoke emphatically.
No one lost their tempers. Occasionally people clapped because they agreed with a speaker. Overall, the people who attended the hearing were very respectful of procedural protocol.
Midway through your article, Nathan Welton wrote, “An armed San Luis Obispo police officer patrolled the room, ostensibly to control the often-rowdy crowd.” This statement is not true. The officer stood in one place most of the time and appeared bored and at times amused. There was no patrolling, and the crowd was not rowdy. One person who spoke candidly about the proposed CDO’s was asked to leave or else be removed. She did not leave and was not removed, and she did not need to be removed. For the record, the crowd was extremely interested in all comments. Ninety percent of the time it was quiet with occasional murmurs or even spoken words-but mostly, quiet.
Your newspaper article stated that Julie Tacker was admonished by Jeffrey Young for clapping. She was wrongly admonished; however, this was not stated in your newspaper. People who read your article might accept this piece of half-truth, unless of course they were at the hearing like I was. Julie never clapped and immediately told Mr. Young that. Your paper however failed to mention the second half of the truth. I know what happened, I was sitting across the aisle from Julie.
Several important facts about the hearing were either omitted by forgetfulness (a serious flaw), or worse, purposely left out (an egregious intentional act). The first huge omission was no mention of our honorable assemblyman Sam Blakeslee’s presence and 10 minute presentation to the Water Board. Sam, who is an excellent extemporaneous speaker, impressed both the Water Board and the attendees. He spoke about his continuing work on trying to have both sides of the sewer issue come together to work out a solution. He spoke of working on legislation to hasten the solution. And he spoke of an upcoming measure by the State Water Board that will affect future waste water management. Not one word was mentioned in your newspaper of Sam’s presence or his important speech. Yet his face is plainly visible in your 4 x 6 inch photo of the hearing on the front page.
Another serious omission was the failure to mention that 3 subpoenas by the people of Los Osos were quashed and not allowed by Mr. Young. These subpoenaed people could have given excellent testimony in cross-examination to support arguments by some of the people who had received proposed CDO’s. This was omitted in your article.
Shirley Bianchi, county supervisor for Los Osos, was at the hearing briefly. She publicly stated that she would only take questions from the board, not from her own constituents. Her self-imposed silence to the very people she represents speaks volumes. This is newsworthy, but Mr. Welton made no reference to Ms. Bianchi’s presence or her total lack of dialogue with the Los Osos citizens.
Overall, the tone of Mr. Welton’s article smacked of emotional drama that portrays the people at the hearing as a rowdy bunch of flaring tempered Los Osans. It is an article that barely gets the potatoes of the hearing and absolutely no meat. This is journalism at it’s nadir. You could have produced a fine piece that got some really important data in print. I resent the bungled attempt of reporting such an important meeting. I resent the stereotype of Los Osos citizenry this article conveys. And I regret that your newspaper can not do a better job at reporting the truth of what really transpires at such important public hearings. The people of Los Osos deserve an apology.
Sincerely,
William R. Moylan
And The Tribune’s Reply:
Dear Mr. Moylan:
Thank you for your submission. Our editors and our reporter have reviewed it and have some suggestions and responses. Normally, the editors would reply to you directly as this is their area of responsibility day in and day out. I’m stepping in because we’re short-handed today and I knew you wanted a prompt reply.
Based on their review, I’m suggesting you rewrite your remarks as a letter to the editor – 200 words is our limit, though if you need a few more, we’ll manage it.
What I’ve done below is cover the main areas of your letter and our response to it. I should note that we emphatically reject your notion that we lack journalistic integrity; we firmly believe we accurately captured the most important elements of the meeting. Reasonable people can disagree about what are the most important elements (e.g., you believe we should have mentioned Sam Blakeslee’s remarks; we disagree. You may be right, but we had to make a decision on deadline with limited space available.)
We decline to print your piece as written because we feel we’d have to rebut your rebuttal. We don’t like to do that. Rather, I encourage you to reconsider your piece and ask you to shorten it so that you can make some points that are important to you. I’ve indicated below some points that might contribute to a valuable discussion of the issues as a letter to the editor.
I hope you will find this approach satisfactory. Separately, please feel free to convey to Julie Tacker our invitation to write a Viewpoint on the overall issue. As you are no doubt aware, we’ve been very accommodating to the board, and I trust from remarks I’ve received from Lisa Schicker that she remains appreciative of The Tribune’s efforts and overall coverage.
Here is our view of the points of contention.
HEADLINE: Reasonable people can disagree about whether the word “ruckus” may have been too strong. The dictionary synonyms are “row” and “disturbance.” I believe “row” – defined in the dictionary as “a noisy disturbance or quarrel” – would cover it, and thus “ruckus” is defensible. But again, reasonable people could argue that words like “disruptive” or “heated” or “passionate” would have been more on the mark in the headline. As I explained to Mr. Martin, the reporter does not write the headline, and in fact he never used the word “ruckus” in his story. This certainly would be a reasonable point for you to make in a letter.
TEMPERS FLARED: Our reporter witnessed booing, hissing, clapping, snide and crass remarks, numerous interruptions (talking over other speakers) throughout the entire session. Our editors believe that justifies the lead sentence; tempers did indeed flare all day long.
ARMED POLICE OFFICER: Regarding the armed police officer: Our reporter witnessed him moving to various locations in the room throughout the day. We used “patrol” to mean the officer was there, and for certain, he did not stay in one spot the entire time. He moved around. Perhaps a better word than “patrol” could have been used, such as “on hand.” I think that is something you can cover in a letter.
SAM BLAKESLEE’S REMARKS: While Sam, whose efforts we have covered all along and given considerable editorial support to, did say he was working on a legislative remedy, he declined to disclose any specifics saying it would be premature to report. So we really had nothing to report.
TACKER CLAPPING: Our reporter did not himself witness her clapping, and did not report as a fact per se that she did. Rather, he reported that the board chairman, sitting in front of the entire group, did admonish her not to clap. He was in a good spot to see if she did or did not. He said she did, and that is what we reported. You suggest that we should have reported that she said she did not. I think that is something that you can cover in a letter to us.
SUBPOENAS: Mr. Martin said to me on the phone yesterday that this is a small point and somewhat beside several other issues. Mr. Martin could not satisfactorily explain to the board (nor to me on the phone) how the subpoenas related to the issue at hand, i.e., whether the families deserved cease and desist orders. So subpoenas were quashed because water board chair did not want to listen to 30 years of history, which was considered irrelevant. I recommend that we leave this issue to another day, when it’s clearer to all involved how this is relevant. Again, I’m merely invoking Mr. Martin’s own admission to me that the subpoenas are not the main issue right now.
I hope this helps and you can find a way to write a compact, trenchant letter to the editor.Sincerely,
Chip Visci
[President and Publisher, Tribune]
And the re-reply:
And here’s the requested 200 word re-write that may or may not appear on the “opinion” page as “opinion,” unlike the original story that appeared on page one and is considered “fact.” Journalism at its finest with the issues shoved off the table. Case closed.
LETTER TO THE EDITOR
The 4/29/06 Tribune headline, “Los Osos raises a ruckus with water officials,” along with the first sentence, “Tempers flared for 12 hours Friday,” convey the impression that throughout the 4/28/06 RWQCB hearing citizens were disorderly, noisy, angry, and unruly. The reporter noted that an officer patrolled the “often rowdy” crowd.
These statements convey an impression of irate citizens roaming the hearing room for hours with placards, chanting slogans, yelling down speakers, engaging in fisticuffs in the back of the room with anyone who dared to disagree, and being hauled off in handcuffs for refusing to relinquish the podium. Available day and night on channel 20 the hearing hardly does justice to the hyperbole, which merely supports and enlivens a broadly unfair stereotype of Los Osos citizens created by the media.
It was probably too much to hope that our county newspaper would afford us the dignity of reporting the RWQCB hearing as it happened. It is discouraging to discover that our own newspaper would use its influence to marginalize and demean Los Osos and its citizens by misrepresentation, by selective reporting, and by false statements and gossip depicted as news. Thank goodness for instant replay.
Beverley A. De Witt-Moylan
Cease and Desist Order Recipient and Defendant
The following letter was sent to the Tribune from the husband of the letter previously posted. He also spent 12 hours at the April 28th hearing and took issue with how the Tribune covered the story the next day. His letter is followed by a reply from the Tribune. Both Moylan’s letters and the reply are extremely instructive if you want to see how a story can be slanted, how headlines can be manipulated (written by somebody who wasn't even there) while all the time denying that any of those techniques are at work. Most interesting is the tactic of suggesting that a “remedy” for what may well be plain old bad reporting is to be had by writing an “opinion” viewpoint which may be printed in the editorial/”opinion” page, thereby clueing the reader in that this is merely “opinion,” while what appeared in the original story is “fact.” If you were at the meeting for 12 hours and/or watched the whole thing on Channel 20, and read the original Tribune story, I invite you to read these letters and reply and see if you understand what the Moylans are objecting to. To me, it’s a familiar complaint when it comes to Los Osos Sewer Reporting.[printed with permission of the Moylans]
April 29, 2006
Dear Chip Visci, Matt Lazier, and Nathan Welton,
Your front page article about the RWQCB hearing was slanted, untrue in parts and lacked ethical integrity.
The title on your front page, “Los Osos raises a ruckus at hearing with water officials,” suggested that there was a commotion or disturbance throughout the hearing. This was not the case. I attended the hearing for the complete 12 ½ hours. The general tone of the hearing was one of a very interested and concerned populace at a controversial meeting. Voices were raised perhaps 4 or 5 times during the entire 12 ½ hours.
The first sentence of your article stated, “Tempers flared for 12 hours…” This is patently untrue. A few people were upset and spoke emphatically.
No one lost their tempers. Occasionally people clapped because they agreed with a speaker. Overall, the people who attended the hearing were very respectful of procedural protocol.
Midway through your article, Nathan Welton wrote, “An armed San Luis Obispo police officer patrolled the room, ostensibly to control the often-rowdy crowd.” This statement is not true. The officer stood in one place most of the time and appeared bored and at times amused. There was no patrolling, and the crowd was not rowdy. One person who spoke candidly about the proposed CDO’s was asked to leave or else be removed. She did not leave and was not removed, and she did not need to be removed. For the record, the crowd was extremely interested in all comments. Ninety percent of the time it was quiet with occasional murmurs or even spoken words-but mostly, quiet.
Your newspaper article stated that Julie Tacker was admonished by Jeffrey Young for clapping. She was wrongly admonished; however, this was not stated in your newspaper. People who read your article might accept this piece of half-truth, unless of course they were at the hearing like I was. Julie never clapped and immediately told Mr. Young that. Your paper however failed to mention the second half of the truth. I know what happened, I was sitting across the aisle from Julie.
Several important facts about the hearing were either omitted by forgetfulness (a serious flaw), or worse, purposely left out (an egregious intentional act). The first huge omission was no mention of our honorable assemblyman Sam Blakeslee’s presence and 10 minute presentation to the Water Board. Sam, who is an excellent extemporaneous speaker, impressed both the Water Board and the attendees. He spoke about his continuing work on trying to have both sides of the sewer issue come together to work out a solution. He spoke of working on legislation to hasten the solution. And he spoke of an upcoming measure by the State Water Board that will affect future waste water management. Not one word was mentioned in your newspaper of Sam’s presence or his important speech. Yet his face is plainly visible in your 4 x 6 inch photo of the hearing on the front page.
Another serious omission was the failure to mention that 3 subpoenas by the people of Los Osos were quashed and not allowed by Mr. Young. These subpoenaed people could have given excellent testimony in cross-examination to support arguments by some of the people who had received proposed CDO’s. This was omitted in your article.
Shirley Bianchi, county supervisor for Los Osos, was at the hearing briefly. She publicly stated that she would only take questions from the board, not from her own constituents. Her self-imposed silence to the very people she represents speaks volumes. This is newsworthy, but Mr. Welton made no reference to Ms. Bianchi’s presence or her total lack of dialogue with the Los Osos citizens.
Overall, the tone of Mr. Welton’s article smacked of emotional drama that portrays the people at the hearing as a rowdy bunch of flaring tempered Los Osans. It is an article that barely gets the potatoes of the hearing and absolutely no meat. This is journalism at it’s nadir. You could have produced a fine piece that got some really important data in print. I resent the bungled attempt of reporting such an important meeting. I resent the stereotype of Los Osos citizenry this article conveys. And I regret that your newspaper can not do a better job at reporting the truth of what really transpires at such important public hearings. The people of Los Osos deserve an apology.
Sincerely,
William R. Moylan
And The Tribune’s Reply:
Dear Mr. Moylan:
Thank you for your submission. Our editors and our reporter have reviewed it and have some suggestions and responses. Normally, the editors would reply to you directly as this is their area of responsibility day in and day out. I’m stepping in because we’re short-handed today and I knew you wanted a prompt reply.
Based on their review, I’m suggesting you rewrite your remarks as a letter to the editor – 200 words is our limit, though if you need a few more, we’ll manage it.
What I’ve done below is cover the main areas of your letter and our response to it. I should note that we emphatically reject your notion that we lack journalistic integrity; we firmly believe we accurately captured the most important elements of the meeting. Reasonable people can disagree about what are the most important elements (e.g., you believe we should have mentioned Sam Blakeslee’s remarks; we disagree. You may be right, but we had to make a decision on deadline with limited space available.)
We decline to print your piece as written because we feel we’d have to rebut your rebuttal. We don’t like to do that. Rather, I encourage you to reconsider your piece and ask you to shorten it so that you can make some points that are important to you. I’ve indicated below some points that might contribute to a valuable discussion of the issues as a letter to the editor.
I hope you will find this approach satisfactory. Separately, please feel free to convey to Julie Tacker our invitation to write a Viewpoint on the overall issue. As you are no doubt aware, we’ve been very accommodating to the board, and I trust from remarks I’ve received from Lisa Schicker that she remains appreciative of The Tribune’s efforts and overall coverage.
Here is our view of the points of contention.
HEADLINE: Reasonable people can disagree about whether the word “ruckus” may have been too strong. The dictionary synonyms are “row” and “disturbance.” I believe “row” – defined in the dictionary as “a noisy disturbance or quarrel” – would cover it, and thus “ruckus” is defensible. But again, reasonable people could argue that words like “disruptive” or “heated” or “passionate” would have been more on the mark in the headline. As I explained to Mr. Martin, the reporter does not write the headline, and in fact he never used the word “ruckus” in his story. This certainly would be a reasonable point for you to make in a letter.
TEMPERS FLARED: Our reporter witnessed booing, hissing, clapping, snide and crass remarks, numerous interruptions (talking over other speakers) throughout the entire session. Our editors believe that justifies the lead sentence; tempers did indeed flare all day long.
ARMED POLICE OFFICER: Regarding the armed police officer: Our reporter witnessed him moving to various locations in the room throughout the day. We used “patrol” to mean the officer was there, and for certain, he did not stay in one spot the entire time. He moved around. Perhaps a better word than “patrol” could have been used, such as “on hand.” I think that is something you can cover in a letter.
SAM BLAKESLEE’S REMARKS: While Sam, whose efforts we have covered all along and given considerable editorial support to, did say he was working on a legislative remedy, he declined to disclose any specifics saying it would be premature to report. So we really had nothing to report.
TACKER CLAPPING: Our reporter did not himself witness her clapping, and did not report as a fact per se that she did. Rather, he reported that the board chairman, sitting in front of the entire group, did admonish her not to clap. He was in a good spot to see if she did or did not. He said she did, and that is what we reported. You suggest that we should have reported that she said she did not. I think that is something that you can cover in a letter to us.
SUBPOENAS: Mr. Martin said to me on the phone yesterday that this is a small point and somewhat beside several other issues. Mr. Martin could not satisfactorily explain to the board (nor to me on the phone) how the subpoenas related to the issue at hand, i.e., whether the families deserved cease and desist orders. So subpoenas were quashed because water board chair did not want to listen to 30 years of history, which was considered irrelevant. I recommend that we leave this issue to another day, when it’s clearer to all involved how this is relevant. Again, I’m merely invoking Mr. Martin’s own admission to me that the subpoenas are not the main issue right now.
I hope this helps and you can find a way to write a compact, trenchant letter to the editor.Sincerely,
Chip Visci
[President and Publisher, Tribune]
And the re-reply:
And here’s the requested 200 word re-write that may or may not appear on the “opinion” page as “opinion,” unlike the original story that appeared on page one and is considered “fact.” Journalism at its finest with the issues shoved off the table. Case closed.
LETTER TO THE EDITOR
The 4/29/06 Tribune headline, “Los Osos raises a ruckus with water officials,” along with the first sentence, “Tempers flared for 12 hours Friday,” convey the impression that throughout the 4/28/06 RWQCB hearing citizens were disorderly, noisy, angry, and unruly. The reporter noted that an officer patrolled the “often rowdy” crowd.
These statements convey an impression of irate citizens roaming the hearing room for hours with placards, chanting slogans, yelling down speakers, engaging in fisticuffs in the back of the room with anyone who dared to disagree, and being hauled off in handcuffs for refusing to relinquish the podium. Available day and night on channel 20 the hearing hardly does justice to the hyperbole, which merely supports and enlivens a broadly unfair stereotype of Los Osos citizens created by the media.
It was probably too much to hope that our county newspaper would afford us the dignity of reporting the RWQCB hearing as it happened. It is discouraging to discover that our own newspaper would use its influence to marginalize and demean Los Osos and its citizens by misrepresentation, by selective reporting, and by false statements and gossip depicted as news. Thank goodness for instant replay.
Beverley A. De Witt-Moylan
Cease and Desist Order Recipient and Defendant
Wednesday, May 03, 2006
Letters, We get Letters
The following was sent to the Tribune from a CDO recipient who spent 12 hours at the April 28 hearing and took issue with how the Tribune covered the story the next day. Printed with permission from the author
Chip Visci, Sandra Duerr, Matt Lazier, Antonio A. Prado, Nathan Welton
The Tribune
3825 S. Higuera
P.O. Box 112
San Luis Obispo, CA 93401
For the past several months I have looked in vain for articles in your newspaper dealing with recipients of Proposed Cease and Desist Orders (CDOs) from the RWQCB. This topic seemed extremely newsworthy from many angles, yet week after week, month after month, you contacted neither my husband and me, nor any Proposed CDO recipient with whom I am familiar. After a showy struggle with the RWQCB to get names of Proposed CDO recipients, you did nothing with the information.
Finally, last week, you printed a story about two retired couples and how they thought a CDO would affect them, were one to be issued. What you have completely missed is the story about what has already happened to those of us who have received Proposed CDOs, the months of work, the personal hardship and expense, the health consequences, the difficulty of fitting research on a site specific prosecution defense around a schedule of work, family, and community responsibilities, and the uncertainties surrounding how much time from these responsibilities will be taken by a hearing, already twelve hours old, which has now been extended for two more days, and could easily go on longer.
On Friday, April 28, 2006, the hearing date, nowhere in your paper did I find any mention whatsoever of the RWQCB hearing. This lack of coverage was surprising given that the random prosecution of 45 Prohibition Zone families, the Designated Parties, was the biggest news in Los Osos that day.
The President and Vice President of the Prohibition Zone Legal Defense Fund (PZLDF) have appeared on local public information outlets. The president called your newspaper to request coverage. No one interviewed either of these gentlemen for an article on this story.
The most egregious of all your omissions occurred on the front page of Saturday’s issue of The Tribune in which Nathan Welton reported his version of the RWQCB hearing. Essentially, you omitted the Truth. The headline, “Los Osos raises a ruckus at hearing with water officials,” along with the first sentence, “Tempers flared for 12 hours Friday,” conveys the impression that throughout the hearing citizens were disorderly, noisy, angry, and unruly. Mr. Welton mentions that, “an armed…officer patrolled the room, ostensibly to control the often rowdy crowd.” While it is true that an armed officer was present, as I would hope to be the case in any public gathering where a large crowd was expected, he did not “patrol.” Since the crowd was so well-behaved, he had very little to do, and for the most part stood or sat in one place for a period of time and then moved to another location, just as many in the crowd did to keep from solidifying as the hours passed. As someone who participated in every minute of the hearing from the center of the room in the second row from 10am to 10:30pm, I can tell you that such hyperbole does not do justice to the reporter, to your newspaper, to the citizens of both Los Osos in particular and of San Luis Obispo County in general, or to the Truth. While at times individuals became emotional, clapped, murmured their dissent, or called out a comment, at no time was the group unruly.
When concerns about crowding in the room emerged early on, citizens left cooperatively, quietly, and respectfully for seats in an overflow room where they could watch the proceedings on television. A group staging a silent demonstration by holding signs in the back of the hall was admonished that they could not carry signs and stay in the room. They left promptly and peacefully. Anyone examining the record would be able to note that the majority of the chairman’s admonitions referred to applause that occurred in response to specific comments. This applause was not loud, raucous, nor prolonged. Citizens maintained remarkable decorum despite the daunting challenges of the months already invested in this struggle and the challenge of waiting all day in vain to present their entire case in the fifteen minutes allotted each household to defend itself. It would have been worth noting for the public at large that these fifteen minutes were the total time we had to present testimony and call witnesses on our behalf.
Mr. Welton had the challenge of reporting the essence of what happened on Friday, yet he chose to use his precious copy space to cover innocuous details, such as the disorganized first part of the hearing and an admonition by the chairman to CSD Director, Julie Tacker, regarding his incorrect belief that she had clapped in response to a specific comment. Though Ms. Tacker denied having clapped, the reporter failed to note that detail, creating the impression that Ms. Tacker’s behavior was, indeed, disorderly.
It is true that inadequate planning by water board staff and its consequent confusion over procedures wasted everyone’s time, but it certainly was not the story. The woman whom the chairman asked be removed by the officer for speaking up vehemently about the disorganization left the microphone as ordered, under her own power, and sat down. Her compliance with the chairman’s directive went unreported. It also went unreported that this was the only instance in over twelve hours when the officer was called upon.
At times, we were treated like school children, but those details also were not the story. In reporting insignificant, irrelevant, half-true, and patently untrue details in order to reinforce a broadly held stereotype of Los Osos citizens, created by the media, Mr. Welton, failed to fulfill his mission as a legitimate news reporter.
Mr. Welton failed to report that the Honorable Sam Blakeslee, our Assemblyman, attended the hearing and addressed the water board about his continuing plans to work on the state level to help find a solution to the Los Osos wastewater issue. Citizens greeted him warmly and respectfully. His face appears in the very large photo accompanying the story on the front page, yet nowhere in the story was Mr. Blakeslee mentioned. His assistant was present with him, and she was present at the end of the hearing, yet she was not mentioned.
Mr. Welton failed to report that District 2 Supervisor Shirley Bianchi also appeared at the hearing, announcing that she would answer questions from the water board only. She refused to take questions from her own constituents. He did not report that Ms. Bianchi had received a subpoena to attend the hearing. He failed to report that the chairman of the water board quashed her subpoena, even though Ms. Bianchi’s testimony would have been critical to the cases of many Designated Parties, and given that she had already indicated that she would not voluntarily cooperate in answering questions from Designated Parties.
Mr. Welton failed to report that Designated Parties had issued at least two other subpoenas, which were also quashed by the chairman of the water board, though the testimony of those witnesses would have been very important to their defense. He did not report that the recipients of these subpoenas had failed to appear that morning, which raised the question of improper prior communications between the board and these subpoena recipients. The chairman addressed this question, himself denying any improper communication with the subpoena recipients, yet that fact went unreported.
Mr. Welton failed to report that the RWQCB chairman addressed the Designated Parties directly, as a group, to determine if we believed that those being prosecuted had not been chosen at random. Receiving a strong affirmative, the chairman stated that the point had been established, and he refused to permit further questions or comments on that issue.
Mr. Welton failed to report that in cross-examination, Dr. Dan Wickam, a wastewater expert witness for the Los Osos CSD, stated that frequent pumping of septic tanks may be in violation of EPA standards and could, therefore, be illegal. This information seems highly newsworthy, at least as newsworthy as the Air Pollution Control District concern that frequent pumping may have an adverse impact on air quality, which the Tribune did report a few days ago. He referred to Dr. Wickam as simply, “Dan Wickam, president of engineering firm AGB,” neglecting to mention Dr. Wickam’s extensive credentials.
Mr. Welton failed to report that Dr. Wickam testified that no definitive, scientific studies have ever been conducted to determine the source of nitrates in the groundwater in Los Osos, that such studies could easily be accomplished at reasonable expense, and that they would show scientifically the source of the nitrates. Mr. Welton did not report that the RWQCB’s contention that septic systems as the source of the nitrates in Los Osos groundwater is essentially speculation based on correlation and not on scientific data, since the water board has conducted no studies. Dr. Wickam cited several possible sources for nitrates, including septic systems, but would not speculate without data provided by scientific tests.
Mr. Welton failed to report that at least three member of the Los Osos CSD addressed the water board. He failed to note that Lisa Schicker, President of the Los Osos CSD, spoke about the CSD’s current efforts in regard to wastewater management to an impassive water board.
To anyone present for the full twelve hours, Mr. Welton’s story gives the impression that he was only briefly in attendance and missed the bulk of the RWQCB hearing. If he did attend the entire hearing, and if his mission was to waste his day finding and inventing innocuous details to support and enliven a stereotype of Los Osos, then he can say, “Mission Accomplished.” If fair and balanced reporting on an extremely significant event in the history of wastewater treatment in Los Osos with its enormous toll on thousands of families in the Prohibition Zone was his goal, then his failure as a competent news reporter is complete.
His supervisors, whose job it is to look at the stories for content, bias, and newsworthiness have failed to protect the public from gossip disguised as journalism. It does not take a journalism major to look at this story and see its flaws. Surely someone who edited the story had to suspect that something was missing. Surely someone asked this reporter what actually HAPPENED at the hearing. If not, then standards for editing at the Tribune are at least as low as its standards for reporting.
These have not been easy months for those of us who have received Proposed CDOs. We are exhausted beyond your understanding. This prosecution has invaded our lives. We take it to work and home again. We eat our meals with it. We sleep with it. We wake up in the night with it. It is there when we help our children with their homework and when we play with our pets. It is there when we talk to our grandchildren on the phone. It is there when we spend time with friends, attend church, or work in our gardens. It sends us to the hospital for emergency treatment for high blood pressure, heart conditions, and stress. It dominates our thoughts.
We are ordinary citizens who have been singled out extraordinarily for prosecution by a government agency for something over which we have no control. Those who have never faced prosecution by an omnipotent government agency have no idea what it is like to try to keep from drowning in the voluminous, necessary research, paperwork, and meetings it takes to mount a defense of our property while conducting the business of everyday life at the same time.
This group of courageous, hard-working, smart, warm, and compassionate people have done this almost alone, ignored by the media, unless we have made the contacts and they have responded. From the uninformed public we have received reactions ranging from, “It’s your own fault,” to “Keep us posted,” to “We feel for you.” We have received none of the attention we are entitled to as your neighbors who are besieged and defenseless. Many of our neighbors had no idea that prosecution awaits them, as well.
It was too much to hope that our county newspaper would afford us the dignity of reporting the RWQCB hearing as it happened. It is discouraging to discover that our own newspaper would use its power for good once again to marginalize and demean Los Osos and its citizens by misrepresentation, by selective reporting, and by false statements and gossip depicted as news.
Sincerely,
Beverley A. De Witt-Moylan
Los Osos Proposed CDO Recipient
The following was sent to the Tribune from a CDO recipient who spent 12 hours at the April 28 hearing and took issue with how the Tribune covered the story the next day. Printed with permission from the author
Chip Visci, Sandra Duerr, Matt Lazier, Antonio A. Prado, Nathan Welton
The Tribune
3825 S. Higuera
P.O. Box 112
San Luis Obispo, CA 93401
For the past several months I have looked in vain for articles in your newspaper dealing with recipients of Proposed Cease and Desist Orders (CDOs) from the RWQCB. This topic seemed extremely newsworthy from many angles, yet week after week, month after month, you contacted neither my husband and me, nor any Proposed CDO recipient with whom I am familiar. After a showy struggle with the RWQCB to get names of Proposed CDO recipients, you did nothing with the information.
Finally, last week, you printed a story about two retired couples and how they thought a CDO would affect them, were one to be issued. What you have completely missed is the story about what has already happened to those of us who have received Proposed CDOs, the months of work, the personal hardship and expense, the health consequences, the difficulty of fitting research on a site specific prosecution defense around a schedule of work, family, and community responsibilities, and the uncertainties surrounding how much time from these responsibilities will be taken by a hearing, already twelve hours old, which has now been extended for two more days, and could easily go on longer.
On Friday, April 28, 2006, the hearing date, nowhere in your paper did I find any mention whatsoever of the RWQCB hearing. This lack of coverage was surprising given that the random prosecution of 45 Prohibition Zone families, the Designated Parties, was the biggest news in Los Osos that day.
The President and Vice President of the Prohibition Zone Legal Defense Fund (PZLDF) have appeared on local public information outlets. The president called your newspaper to request coverage. No one interviewed either of these gentlemen for an article on this story.
The most egregious of all your omissions occurred on the front page of Saturday’s issue of The Tribune in which Nathan Welton reported his version of the RWQCB hearing. Essentially, you omitted the Truth. The headline, “Los Osos raises a ruckus at hearing with water officials,” along with the first sentence, “Tempers flared for 12 hours Friday,” conveys the impression that throughout the hearing citizens were disorderly, noisy, angry, and unruly. Mr. Welton mentions that, “an armed…officer patrolled the room, ostensibly to control the often rowdy crowd.” While it is true that an armed officer was present, as I would hope to be the case in any public gathering where a large crowd was expected, he did not “patrol.” Since the crowd was so well-behaved, he had very little to do, and for the most part stood or sat in one place for a period of time and then moved to another location, just as many in the crowd did to keep from solidifying as the hours passed. As someone who participated in every minute of the hearing from the center of the room in the second row from 10am to 10:30pm, I can tell you that such hyperbole does not do justice to the reporter, to your newspaper, to the citizens of both Los Osos in particular and of San Luis Obispo County in general, or to the Truth. While at times individuals became emotional, clapped, murmured their dissent, or called out a comment, at no time was the group unruly.
When concerns about crowding in the room emerged early on, citizens left cooperatively, quietly, and respectfully for seats in an overflow room where they could watch the proceedings on television. A group staging a silent demonstration by holding signs in the back of the hall was admonished that they could not carry signs and stay in the room. They left promptly and peacefully. Anyone examining the record would be able to note that the majority of the chairman’s admonitions referred to applause that occurred in response to specific comments. This applause was not loud, raucous, nor prolonged. Citizens maintained remarkable decorum despite the daunting challenges of the months already invested in this struggle and the challenge of waiting all day in vain to present their entire case in the fifteen minutes allotted each household to defend itself. It would have been worth noting for the public at large that these fifteen minutes were the total time we had to present testimony and call witnesses on our behalf.
Mr. Welton had the challenge of reporting the essence of what happened on Friday, yet he chose to use his precious copy space to cover innocuous details, such as the disorganized first part of the hearing and an admonition by the chairman to CSD Director, Julie Tacker, regarding his incorrect belief that she had clapped in response to a specific comment. Though Ms. Tacker denied having clapped, the reporter failed to note that detail, creating the impression that Ms. Tacker’s behavior was, indeed, disorderly.
It is true that inadequate planning by water board staff and its consequent confusion over procedures wasted everyone’s time, but it certainly was not the story. The woman whom the chairman asked be removed by the officer for speaking up vehemently about the disorganization left the microphone as ordered, under her own power, and sat down. Her compliance with the chairman’s directive went unreported. It also went unreported that this was the only instance in over twelve hours when the officer was called upon.
At times, we were treated like school children, but those details also were not the story. In reporting insignificant, irrelevant, half-true, and patently untrue details in order to reinforce a broadly held stereotype of Los Osos citizens, created by the media, Mr. Welton, failed to fulfill his mission as a legitimate news reporter.
Mr. Welton failed to report that the Honorable Sam Blakeslee, our Assemblyman, attended the hearing and addressed the water board about his continuing plans to work on the state level to help find a solution to the Los Osos wastewater issue. Citizens greeted him warmly and respectfully. His face appears in the very large photo accompanying the story on the front page, yet nowhere in the story was Mr. Blakeslee mentioned. His assistant was present with him, and she was present at the end of the hearing, yet she was not mentioned.
Mr. Welton failed to report that District 2 Supervisor Shirley Bianchi also appeared at the hearing, announcing that she would answer questions from the water board only. She refused to take questions from her own constituents. He did not report that Ms. Bianchi had received a subpoena to attend the hearing. He failed to report that the chairman of the water board quashed her subpoena, even though Ms. Bianchi’s testimony would have been critical to the cases of many Designated Parties, and given that she had already indicated that she would not voluntarily cooperate in answering questions from Designated Parties.
Mr. Welton failed to report that Designated Parties had issued at least two other subpoenas, which were also quashed by the chairman of the water board, though the testimony of those witnesses would have been very important to their defense. He did not report that the recipients of these subpoenas had failed to appear that morning, which raised the question of improper prior communications between the board and these subpoena recipients. The chairman addressed this question, himself denying any improper communication with the subpoena recipients, yet that fact went unreported.
Mr. Welton failed to report that the RWQCB chairman addressed the Designated Parties directly, as a group, to determine if we believed that those being prosecuted had not been chosen at random. Receiving a strong affirmative, the chairman stated that the point had been established, and he refused to permit further questions or comments on that issue.
Mr. Welton failed to report that in cross-examination, Dr. Dan Wickam, a wastewater expert witness for the Los Osos CSD, stated that frequent pumping of septic tanks may be in violation of EPA standards and could, therefore, be illegal. This information seems highly newsworthy, at least as newsworthy as the Air Pollution Control District concern that frequent pumping may have an adverse impact on air quality, which the Tribune did report a few days ago. He referred to Dr. Wickam as simply, “Dan Wickam, president of engineering firm AGB,” neglecting to mention Dr. Wickam’s extensive credentials.
Mr. Welton failed to report that Dr. Wickam testified that no definitive, scientific studies have ever been conducted to determine the source of nitrates in the groundwater in Los Osos, that such studies could easily be accomplished at reasonable expense, and that they would show scientifically the source of the nitrates. Mr. Welton did not report that the RWQCB’s contention that septic systems as the source of the nitrates in Los Osos groundwater is essentially speculation based on correlation and not on scientific data, since the water board has conducted no studies. Dr. Wickam cited several possible sources for nitrates, including septic systems, but would not speculate without data provided by scientific tests.
Mr. Welton failed to report that at least three member of the Los Osos CSD addressed the water board. He failed to note that Lisa Schicker, President of the Los Osos CSD, spoke about the CSD’s current efforts in regard to wastewater management to an impassive water board.
To anyone present for the full twelve hours, Mr. Welton’s story gives the impression that he was only briefly in attendance and missed the bulk of the RWQCB hearing. If he did attend the entire hearing, and if his mission was to waste his day finding and inventing innocuous details to support and enliven a stereotype of Los Osos, then he can say, “Mission Accomplished.” If fair and balanced reporting on an extremely significant event in the history of wastewater treatment in Los Osos with its enormous toll on thousands of families in the Prohibition Zone was his goal, then his failure as a competent news reporter is complete.
His supervisors, whose job it is to look at the stories for content, bias, and newsworthiness have failed to protect the public from gossip disguised as journalism. It does not take a journalism major to look at this story and see its flaws. Surely someone who edited the story had to suspect that something was missing. Surely someone asked this reporter what actually HAPPENED at the hearing. If not, then standards for editing at the Tribune are at least as low as its standards for reporting.
These have not been easy months for those of us who have received Proposed CDOs. We are exhausted beyond your understanding. This prosecution has invaded our lives. We take it to work and home again. We eat our meals with it. We sleep with it. We wake up in the night with it. It is there when we help our children with their homework and when we play with our pets. It is there when we talk to our grandchildren on the phone. It is there when we spend time with friends, attend church, or work in our gardens. It sends us to the hospital for emergency treatment for high blood pressure, heart conditions, and stress. It dominates our thoughts.
We are ordinary citizens who have been singled out extraordinarily for prosecution by a government agency for something over which we have no control. Those who have never faced prosecution by an omnipotent government agency have no idea what it is like to try to keep from drowning in the voluminous, necessary research, paperwork, and meetings it takes to mount a defense of our property while conducting the business of everyday life at the same time.
This group of courageous, hard-working, smart, warm, and compassionate people have done this almost alone, ignored by the media, unless we have made the contacts and they have responded. From the uninformed public we have received reactions ranging from, “It’s your own fault,” to “Keep us posted,” to “We feel for you.” We have received none of the attention we are entitled to as your neighbors who are besieged and defenseless. Many of our neighbors had no idea that prosecution awaits them, as well.
It was too much to hope that our county newspaper would afford us the dignity of reporting the RWQCB hearing as it happened. It is discouraging to discover that our own newspaper would use its power for good once again to marginalize and demean Los Osos and its citizens by misrepresentation, by selective reporting, and by false statements and gossip depicted as news.
Sincerely,
Beverley A. De Witt-Moylan
Los Osos Proposed CDO Recipient
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)