I OBJECT!
In which Los Osos 45er, Beverly A. De Witt- Moylan, submitted Procedural Objections to the RWQCB at their May 11th procedural hearing. Bet you and all normal people in Los Osos, living your busy lives and going to work and raising your families, thought the CDOs and all things CDOish had been postponed pending getting a new prosecution team & etc. Bwahahahah. Nope. That’s how government agencies go about fooling all the people all of the time, when they wish. It’s called “fine print bureaucratic argle-bargle” and if you don’t understand it, you can have your rights slipped right out from under you and when you complain you’re told, “Oh, too bad, please see page 922, sub paragraph 27A, you had a chance to comment or amend or submit procedural matters but you didn’t show up so it’s now too late, heh-heh.”
Bev noted in an email that she, like most everyone else, also didn’t understand that the meeting was still on and so had to rush in her objections. Wrote Bev, “According to Bill, [her husband], Jeffery Young tried to get him to stop, but Bill continued to read my objections till he was done. Bill said about 35 people were in attendance . . . If I had more time,” said she, “I would have thought of more.” Duh.
RWQCB HEARING
PROCEDURAL OBJECTIONS
-I OBJECT TO THE RWQCB’s UTTER FAILURE TO PROPERLY NOTIFY ME OF A PROPOSED CDO, MAILING IT INSTEAD IN A PLAIN MANILA ENVELOPE THROUGH REGULAR MAIL WITH NO INDICATION THAT IT WAS IMPORTANT AND NEEDED TO BE OPENED IMMEDIATELY.
-I OBJECT TO BEING THREATENED WITH FINES OF $1000 PER DAY FOR NOT REVEALING THE NAMES OF EVERY RESIDENT AND TENANT ON MY PROPERTY WITHIN 5 DAYS OF RECEIPT OF THE PROPOSED CDO.
-I OBJECT TO BEING DENIED MY RIGHT TO DUE PROCESS BY BEING DENIED AN INDIVIDUAL HEARING
-I OBJECT TO BEING GIVEN NO MORE THAN 15 MINUTES TOGETHER WITH MY HUSBAND TO PRESENT OUR DEFENSE, WHEN THE DOCUMENTS WE RECEIVED STATED THAT EACH CDO RECIPIENT WOULD HAVE 15 MINUTES TO PRESENT THEIR CASE.
-I OBJECT TO ANY TIME LIMITATION ON OUR PRESENTATIONS GIVEN THE SERIOUSNESS OF THE CONSEQUENCES OF CONVICTION, NAMELY THAT, IF NO WASTEWATER TREATMENT SYSTEM IS AVAILABLE ON JANUARY 1, 2010, “YOU WILL HAVE TO VACATE THE PREMISES.” –Matt Thompson, April 28, 2006
-I OBJECT TO THE CHAIRMAN’S RULING THAT THE PROPERTY IS THE CDO RECIPIENT AS A JUSTIFICATION FOR COMBINING PRESENTATIONS BY SPOUSES. ACCORDING TO THE DOCUMENTS, THE PROPERTY IS NOT THE DEFENDANT, THE PROPERTY IS NOT THE POLLUTER, THE PROPERTY WILL NOT BE PAYING FOR BIMONTHLY PUMPING, THE PROPERTY WILL NOT “HAVE TO VACATE THE PREMISES.”
-I OBJECT TO THE GENDER BIAS BEING DEMONSTRATED BY THIS BOARD IN THAT ALL CORRESPONDENCE FROM THE RWQCB IS ADDRESSED TO MY HUSBAND ONLY. IN THE EVIDENCE I SUBMITTED PRIOR TO THE APRIL 5, 2006, DEADLINE I IDENTIFIED MYSELF BY MY FULL, LEGAL NAME. AT THE APRIL 28, 2006, HEARING I IDENTIFIED MYSELF AT LEAST THREE TIMES FOR THE RECORD BY MY FULL, LEGAL NAME. I HAVE BEEN ADDRESSED ONLY BY MY HUSBAND’S NAME, AND THE TWO MOST RECENT COMMUNICATIONS FROM THE RWQCB TO OUR PROPERTY HAVE BEEN ADDRESSED TO MR. BILL MOYLAN ONLY. NOT ONLY AM I COMPLETELY OVERLOOKED AS A CO-OWNER WITH MY HUSBAND OF THE PROPERTY, BUT THE RWQCB STAFF HAS ALSO DROPPED THE USE OF MY HUSBAND’S LEGAL NAME, AS WELL.
-I OBJECT TO BEING CALLED AWAY FROM MY JOB SERVING BLIND AND VISUALLY IMPAIRED CHILDREN IN THIS COUNTY, BEING UNABLE TO GET A SUBSTITUTE BECAUSE OF THE SPECIALIZATION OF MY CREDENTIAL, YET SUFFERING THE PENALTY OF FORFEITING ANY DEFENSE IF I DID NOT APPEAR.
-I OBJECT TO BEING ADVISED THAT MY HUSBAND COULD REPRESENT ME IN THE EVENT I COULD NOT APPEAR, WHEREAS, WHEN MY HUSBAND TOLD THE CHAIRMAN THAT HE WOULD BE OUT OF TOWN WERE THE HEARING TO BE CONTINUED INTO THE FOLLOWING WEEK, THE CHAIRMAN AGREED THAT WE COULD PRESENT AT THE BEGINNING AND DID NOT ASK HIM IF I WOULD BE AVAILABLE TO REPRESENT HIM. THE DOUBLE STANDARD FOR ONE SPOUSE REPRESENTING ANOTHER IS EVEN MORE EVIDENCE OF GENDER BIAS ON THE PART OF THE RWQCB IN DEALING WITH MARRIED COUPLES.
-I OBJECT TO BEING DENIED MY RIGHT TO EQUAL PROTECTION UNDER THE LAW IN BEING SINGLED OUT AS A TEST CASE FOR PROSECUTION WITH 44 OTHER FAMILIES WHO WILL HAVE TO PAY OUT MORE IN PUNITIVE COSTS, IF ANY ARE IMPOSED, THAN ANYONE ELSE IN THE PROHIBITION ZONE AND WHOSE SEPTIC SYSTEM WILL BE MORE ADVERSELY AFFECTED BY PUMPING THAN ANYONE ELSE IN THE PROHIBITION ZONE.
-I OBJECT THAT I HAVE NOT BEEN OFFERED THE SERVICES OF A PUBLIC DEFENDER.
-I OBJECT TO BEING REQUIRED TO DEFEND MYSELF AGAINST UNSUBSTANTIATED CHARGES AND BEING CRIMINALIZED FOR LIVING IN A SECTION OF LOS OSOS ARBITRARILY DEFINED BY THIS BOARD AS THE AREA WHERE THE POLLUTERS LIVE WHILE EVERYONE ELSE OUTSIDE THIS ZONE IS DEFINED AS CLEAN.
-I OBJECT TO THE AMOUNT OF MISINFORMATION, CONFUSING COMMUNICATION, CONFLICTING COMMUNICATION, REVISIONS TO COMMUNICATIONS, AND INCONSISTENCIES IN COMMUNICATIONS FROM THIS STAFF, INCLUDING OUR INABILITY TO GET A SIMPLE, CONSISTENT ANSWER REGARDING THE DATE THAT EVIDENCE WAS DUE IN SACRAMENTO.
-I OBJECT TO DISINGENUOUS STATEMENTS MADE BY THE PROSECUTION STAFF IN ITS REBUTTAL TO THE EVIDENCE THAT THEIR DOCUMENTS IN EVIDENCE WERE AVAILABLE DURING BUSINESS HOURS AT THEIR SITE. THE DELIBERATE INCONVENIENCE AND LACK OF AVAILABILITY OF THESE DOCUMENTS WITH NO CITATION OF RELEVANCE OF INDIVIDUAL DOCUMENTS FORCED CITIZENS TO TAKE TIME OFF WORK OR AWAY FROM FAMILY RESPONSIBILITIES DURING BUSINESS HOURS TO REVIEW IN LIMITED TIME THOUSANDS OF PAGES STORED IN A BACK ROOM IN A CARDBOARD BOX. AT THE SAME TIME PROSECUTION STAFF REQUESTED THAT OUR DOCUMENTS BE SUBMITTED IN PDF FORM, OSTENSIBLY SO THAT THEY COULD PERUSE THESE DOCUMENTS AT THEIR LEISURE.
-I OBJECT TO AND AM DISTURBED BY THE RWQCB SUBMITTING REVISED CDO’S ON THE DATE OUR EVIDENCE WAS DUE, WHICH WE DID NOT RECEIVE IN THE MAIL UNTIL APRIL 11, 2006.
-I OBJECT TO THE RWQCB’S SUBMISSION OF FURTHER REVISIONS TO THE CDOs, WHICH WE RECEIVED BY COURIER ON APRIL 26, 2006, LESS THAN TWO DAYS BEFORE THE HEARING, AND TOO LATE FOR US TO RESPOND TO, SINCE ANY EVIDENCE WE MIGHT HAVE PROFERRED WAS DUE NO LATER THAN APRIL 5, 2006, AND NO REVISION TO THAT DATE WAS FORTHCOMING.
-I OBJECT TO RECEIVING THE RWQCB OBJECTIONS TO EVIDENCE BY EMAIL TRANSMISSION LESS THAN 24 HOURS PRIOR TO THE HEARING AND BY HARD COPY THE DAY OF THE HEARING. RULES OF EVIDENCE FOR PURPOSES OF THIS HEARING IN WHICH 45 LEGALLY UNSOPHISTICATED FAMILIES WOULD BE PRESENTING THEIR EVIDENCE OUGHT TO HAVE BEEN CLARIFIED UPON ISSUANCE OF THE CDOS. SENATOR SUSAN COLLINS OF MAINE RECENTLY STATED THAT “THE FIRST OBLIGATION OF GOVERNMENT IS TO PROTECT OUR PEOPLE.” IN THEIR ZEAL FOR PROSECUTION THIS BOARD HAS COMPLETELY FORGOTTEN THAT THE CITIZENS LIVING IN THE PROHIBITION ZONE ARE “OUR PEOPLE.” THIS BOARD HAD AN OBLIGATION TO THE HARD-WORKING CITIZENS OF LOS OSOS WHO HAVE HAD TO MOUNT A DEFENSE IN WHATEVER SPARE TIME THEY MIGHT HAVE HAD BETWEEN WORK, FAMILY, AND COMMUNITY OBLIGATIONS. THIS BOARD OWED THE CITIZENS OF THE PROHIBITION ZONE THE COMMON COURTESY TO PROVIDE THEM WITH CORRECT INFORMATION AT THE OUTSET OF THIS ACTION, SO THEY WOULD NOT SPEND TIME ON EVIDENCE THAT WOULD BE REJECTED BECAUSE OF ITS SOURCE OR FORMAT.
-I OBJECT TO THE USE OF BIMONTHLY PUMPING AS THE REMEDY OF CHOICE WHEN, ACCORDING TO A PROSECUTION STAFF STATEMENT AT THE INFORMATIONAL MEETING IN FEBRUARY, THIS CONCEPT IS “UNHEARD OF.”
-I OBJECT TO THE WATER BOARD’S RECOMMENDATION OF A SOLUTION WHICH, IN THE WORDS OF ITS OWN STAFF, HAS NEVER BEEN TRIED AND YET IS BEING PROPOSED WITH CONFIDENT VEHEMENCE BY THE PROSECUTION AS THE ONLY POSSIBLE WAY TO KEEP UNSCIENTIFICALLY PROVEN POLLUTION FROM CONTINUING TO AFFECT THE GROUNDWATER.
-I OBJECT TO THE LANGUAGE IN THE RWQCB REBUTTAL ON PAGE 7 OF THE LEGAL OBJECTIONS STATING THAT “TAKING ENFORCEMENT ACTION IS APPARENTLY THE ONLY WAY THE WATER BOARD CAN PROTECT PUBLIC HEALTH AND SAFETY IN THIS CASE, GIVEN THE COMMUNITY’S “RAMPANT AND LONGSTANDING DISREGARD OF THE PROHIBITION.” THIS HYPERBOLE IS QUITE THE OPPOSITE OF THE WATER BOARD’S POSITION IN ITS STAFF REPORT FOR REGULAR MEETING OF JULY 9, 2004 IN ITS BACKGROUND SECTION WHERE IT CITES NUMEROUS CIRCUMSTANCES WHICH PUT OUR TIMELY CONNECTION TO A WASTEWATER TREATMENT SYSTEM OUT OF OUR HANDS. ON PAGE 2 OF THIS DOCUMENT THE RWQCB INDICATES THAT, “PROJECT DELAYS, AND NONCOMPLIANCE WITH THE TIME SCHEDULE ORDER, ARE CLEARLY BEYOND THE LOS OSOS CSD’S ABILITY TO CONTROL”. ON PAGE 3 “INDIVIDUALS HAVE VERY LIMITED MEANS OF EFFECTIVELY CEASING DISCHARGES UNTIL A COMMUNITY SEWER SYSTEM IS AVAILABLE.” AND ON PAGE 4 “IT SHOULD BE NOTED, HOWEVER, THAT THE VAST MAJORITY OF VOTERS IN LOS OSOS HAVE SUPPORTED THE PROJECT AT EVERY STEP.” I OBJECT THAT IN 2004 THE WATER BOARD REASONABLY AND PRUDENTLY ACKNOWLEDGED THE MANY OBSTACLES PREVENTING BOTH THE CSD AND INDIVIDUALS FROM SUCCESSFULLY IMPLEMENTING A WASTEWATER TREATMENT FACILITY, YET JUST TWO YEARS LATER RESIDENTS OF THE PROHIBITION ZONE ARE DRAMATICALLY CHARACTERIZED AS HAVING DEMONSTRATED “RAMPANT AND LONGSTANDING DISREGARD OF THE PROHIBITION.” THIS STATEMENT IS OFFENSIVE AND PATENTLY UNTRUE.
Friday, May 12, 2006
A Dollar Short and Twenty Years Too Late
Oh, Hello, Tribune. Hope you had a nice twenty-year nap? Glad you could join us.
I see in your May 12 editorial, “A wise way for Los Osos to repay itself,” you’re now championing the formation of a septic tank maintenance district. Sez you, “A septic tank maintenance district is long over due for all of Los Osos – including those residents using septics outside the sewer’s zone of prohibition. It’s a fair and equitable approach that makes the whole community responsible for the quality of its water basin.”
Gosh, ya think?
Starting in the 80s, with the RWQCB’s Resolution 83-12, Citizens for an Affordable Wastewater System (CAWS, remember them?) and others repeatedly called upon the County, the Regional Water Quality Control Board and the first CSD board to form just such a district. Oh, and while they were at it, to please enlarge the prohibition zone to include all septics. And if a building moratorium was going to be imposed, slap it on everyone in the watershed. And so forth.
Here’s what the constant reply was, even from regulators who have the words “Water Quality” in their name: NO.
For twenty-some years, it’s been, NO to a septic management district, NO to updating the basin plan, NO to enlarging the prohibition zone (NOTE: Oops, someone who logged on to comment on this blog entry pointed out this muddlement: I meant to say that the original prohibition zone was always scientifically indefensible. Enlarging it was and is the only scientifically sensible thing to do, especially with the State septics rules in the form of AB885 coming down the pike), NO to dealing with the larger issues of water and watershed protection. NO to new technologies. NO to interim mitigation. NO to innovative solutions. NO. NO. NO.
It is a supreme irony that so many citizens of Los Osos were ahead of the curve on this one, yet, despite evidence to the contrary, it was the government agencies responsible who refused to deal proactively with growing problems and instead headed single-mindedly to the train wreck we see today.
Aided and abetted, of course, by the “newspaper of record” that has been asleep at the switch all along.
Well, all I can say is, From the Trib’s lips to God’s ears. Let’s hope the state Legislature is listening?
Oh, Hello, Tribune. Hope you had a nice twenty-year nap? Glad you could join us.
I see in your May 12 editorial, “A wise way for Los Osos to repay itself,” you’re now championing the formation of a septic tank maintenance district. Sez you, “A septic tank maintenance district is long over due for all of Los Osos – including those residents using septics outside the sewer’s zone of prohibition. It’s a fair and equitable approach that makes the whole community responsible for the quality of its water basin.”
Gosh, ya think?
Starting in the 80s, with the RWQCB’s Resolution 83-12, Citizens for an Affordable Wastewater System (CAWS, remember them?) and others repeatedly called upon the County, the Regional Water Quality Control Board and the first CSD board to form just such a district. Oh, and while they were at it, to please enlarge the prohibition zone to include all septics. And if a building moratorium was going to be imposed, slap it on everyone in the watershed. And so forth.
Here’s what the constant reply was, even from regulators who have the words “Water Quality” in their name: NO.
For twenty-some years, it’s been, NO to a septic management district, NO to updating the basin plan, NO to enlarging the prohibition zone (NOTE: Oops, someone who logged on to comment on this blog entry pointed out this muddlement: I meant to say that the original prohibition zone was always scientifically indefensible. Enlarging it was and is the only scientifically sensible thing to do, especially with the State septics rules in the form of AB885 coming down the pike), NO to dealing with the larger issues of water and watershed protection. NO to new technologies. NO to interim mitigation. NO to innovative solutions. NO. NO. NO.
It is a supreme irony that so many citizens of Los Osos were ahead of the curve on this one, yet, despite evidence to the contrary, it was the government agencies responsible who refused to deal proactively with growing problems and instead headed single-mindedly to the train wreck we see today.
Aided and abetted, of course, by the “newspaper of record” that has been asleep at the switch all along.
Well, all I can say is, From the Trib’s lips to God’s ears. Let’s hope the state Legislature is listening?
Thursday, May 11, 2006
Calhoun’s Cannons, The Bay News, Morro Bay, CA
for May 12.06
No, Thanks, I’ll just stab myself in the eyeballs for 12 hours instead
To be persuasive, we must be believable. To be believable, we must be credible. To be credible, we must be truthful.
Edward R. Murrow
If you want to understand how a scientifically challenged staff of a government agency planned to paralyze then destroy a whole community with a scientifically unsound, poorly planned scheme, and if you missed the actual hearings, then tune into Channel 20 for the 12 hour film entitled, “The Mad Hatter’s Tea Party Meets The Bataan Death March” aka “The CDO Trial of the Los Osos 45,” now being held-over by the Regional Water Quality Control Board.
You, too, can watch and wonder, as I did sitting in the audience, how in living hell they’re going to process and hear from 5,000 people at 15 minutes each, plus cross examination and questioning witnesses and you do the math in your head or on a little scrap of paper and it comes out a minimum of one hundred twenty five 10-hour days and you say, Sweet Jesus, didn’t RWQCB CEO Roger Briggs think about all this when he cooked up this insane scheme and realize he’s screwed up big time, especially when the Air Pollution Control Guy showed up to say, Nuh-huh, ya gotta do more research on all those diesel trucks, 82 pumps a day, 6 days a week, all going chugga-chugga, but then when he’s asked if he intends to continue processing not just the 45 but the whole town and his eyes squint down and he says Yes, thereby proving he is incapable of dealing with reality checks or informational feed-back loops, so you pray his Board will have enough sense to burst out laughing or jump up and cry THIS IS INSANE, STOP IT RIGHT NOW, WHO THOUGHT UP THE COCKAMAMIE SCHEME, ANYWAY, but they don’t, so they sit there hour after hour after hour, Prisoners of Folly.
Tune in to see the RWQCB’s own Mr. Staff Science Guy, whose lack of training on anything septic is cringe-makingly inadequate, whose grasp of the Los Osos water system makes it clear he thinks we’re all rolling around out here with pigs, like Moonbeam McShine, swilling down nitrate-laden drinking water that violates state standards, (it doesn’t, we aren’t), then watch in amazement when RWQCB’s CEO Roger Briggs is asked, under oath, if he has any direct empirical evidence (you know, like isotope tests) showing that the Los Osos 45 are actually polluting the waters of the State of California and he says, no, no actual, empirical evidence, he’s just acting on “presumption” and “common knowledge,” like in the old days when it was “common knowledge” that witches soured milk in barns so it would make sense to spend $200 million to string a witch-catching net all over a town, until Dr. Wickham, B.S. M.S. Ph.D, owner of ABG Wastewater Solution, the outfit that’s installed the Pirana System of bio-remediation at the firehouse, gets up there and blam-blam-blam, the Board and audience gets a non-stop detailed lecture on all things septic, including Dr. Wickham’s observation that pumping tanks 6 times a year will end up destroying the mature biological colonies that make the system work properly, that pumping that frequently will make discharges worse, will have no appreciable effect on the groundwater, will lead to leach field failures all over town within two years, and when asked if there were a safer plan than pumping, replied, Yes, NOT pumping.
And then a member of the RWQC Prosecution Staff asks, Are there any cost-comparable onsite systems that could be used to achieve a similar nitrate load reduction that pumping was supposed to achieve and he cheerfully replied, Oh, yes, many, and I had to ask myself, Why is that question being asked NOW?
Is it possible the RWQCB staff never asked and answered that question BEFORE terrorizing this town, before wasting gazillions of hours of taxpayer’s time and money, before wasting their Board’s time (twelve hours so far, ten years to go), and instead just ran with the stupidest, most destructive, most scientifically unsound, indefensible cockamamie scheme that popped off the top of their Mad Hatter heads?
The answer to that question is why you need to watch the proceedings. Pay attention, Los Osos, you are being played for fools by a dangerous, out-of-control, incompetent, ill-prepared regulatory staff playing at personal politics instead of acting on sound science and prudent public policy.
for May 12.06
No, Thanks, I’ll just stab myself in the eyeballs for 12 hours instead
To be persuasive, we must be believable. To be believable, we must be credible. To be credible, we must be truthful.
Edward R. Murrow
If you want to understand how a scientifically challenged staff of a government agency planned to paralyze then destroy a whole community with a scientifically unsound, poorly planned scheme, and if you missed the actual hearings, then tune into Channel 20 for the 12 hour film entitled, “The Mad Hatter’s Tea Party Meets The Bataan Death March” aka “The CDO Trial of the Los Osos 45,” now being held-over by the Regional Water Quality Control Board.
You, too, can watch and wonder, as I did sitting in the audience, how in living hell they’re going to process and hear from 5,000 people at 15 minutes each, plus cross examination and questioning witnesses and you do the math in your head or on a little scrap of paper and it comes out a minimum of one hundred twenty five 10-hour days and you say, Sweet Jesus, didn’t RWQCB CEO Roger Briggs think about all this when he cooked up this insane scheme and realize he’s screwed up big time, especially when the Air Pollution Control Guy showed up to say, Nuh-huh, ya gotta do more research on all those diesel trucks, 82 pumps a day, 6 days a week, all going chugga-chugga, but then when he’s asked if he intends to continue processing not just the 45 but the whole town and his eyes squint down and he says Yes, thereby proving he is incapable of dealing with reality checks or informational feed-back loops, so you pray his Board will have enough sense to burst out laughing or jump up and cry THIS IS INSANE, STOP IT RIGHT NOW, WHO THOUGHT UP THE COCKAMAMIE SCHEME, ANYWAY, but they don’t, so they sit there hour after hour after hour, Prisoners of Folly.
Tune in to see the RWQCB’s own Mr. Staff Science Guy, whose lack of training on anything septic is cringe-makingly inadequate, whose grasp of the Los Osos water system makes it clear he thinks we’re all rolling around out here with pigs, like Moonbeam McShine, swilling down nitrate-laden drinking water that violates state standards, (it doesn’t, we aren’t), then watch in amazement when RWQCB’s CEO Roger Briggs is asked, under oath, if he has any direct empirical evidence (you know, like isotope tests) showing that the Los Osos 45 are actually polluting the waters of the State of California and he says, no, no actual, empirical evidence, he’s just acting on “presumption” and “common knowledge,” like in the old days when it was “common knowledge” that witches soured milk in barns so it would make sense to spend $200 million to string a witch-catching net all over a town, until Dr. Wickham, B.S. M.S. Ph.D, owner of ABG Wastewater Solution, the outfit that’s installed the Pirana System of bio-remediation at the firehouse, gets up there and blam-blam-blam, the Board and audience gets a non-stop detailed lecture on all things septic, including Dr. Wickham’s observation that pumping tanks 6 times a year will end up destroying the mature biological colonies that make the system work properly, that pumping that frequently will make discharges worse, will have no appreciable effect on the groundwater, will lead to leach field failures all over town within two years, and when asked if there were a safer plan than pumping, replied, Yes, NOT pumping.
And then a member of the RWQC Prosecution Staff asks, Are there any cost-comparable onsite systems that could be used to achieve a similar nitrate load reduction that pumping was supposed to achieve and he cheerfully replied, Oh, yes, many, and I had to ask myself, Why is that question being asked NOW?
Is it possible the RWQCB staff never asked and answered that question BEFORE terrorizing this town, before wasting gazillions of hours of taxpayer’s time and money, before wasting their Board’s time (twelve hours so far, ten years to go), and instead just ran with the stupidest, most destructive, most scientifically unsound, indefensible cockamamie scheme that popped off the top of their Mad Hatter heads?
The answer to that question is why you need to watch the proceedings. Pay attention, Los Osos, you are being played for fools by a dangerous, out-of-control, incompetent, ill-prepared regulatory staff playing at personal politics instead of acting on sound science and prudent public policy.
Wednesday, May 10, 2006
And now, another Letter (and see UPDATE posted below)
The following letter-to-the-editor appeared in the Tribune May 9th by Beverly A. De Witt-Moylan of Los Osos (She’s one of the Los Osos 45 served with a CDO) Her letter speaks to something that I found fascinating here in Sewerville: How quickly certain folks moved to dissolve the CSD that many of them, ironically, had struggled so hard to create in the first place when a recall didn’t go their way. No town meetings for them, no open debates, no compromise, no new candidates, no input or even new initiatives, no working on committees, no re-recalls (wouldn't that have been fun?), no use of any of the tools in the “democratic” tool chest except --- Blam! -- out of the box – dissolve the whole CSD. End game. No ninth-grade civics for them. Nosir!
It remains one of the most fascinating elements of this whole strange trip. Clearly, Sewervillers ain’t New Englanders, more’s the pity.
Growing up in New England, town meetings were a way of life for me.
Every week in March, my parents met our neighbors at the Town Hall to debate and vote on the town budget for the year. Into the night they amended and revised our local bylaws, item by item, with the Board of Selectmen, our town’s governing body.
This purest form of democracy continues to thrive in many communities across the Northeast. Though some have joked that we threw off the bonds of England only to be free to tax ourselves, the representative democracy that emerged from the American Revolution is the best embodiment of the concept in the world today.
Anyone who benefits from self-governance has a stake in democracy. Having only recently gained the right to local control, Los Osos struggles now with forces working to solve local problems by dissolving local government.
Ninth-grade civics teaches that the foundation of democracy is compromise, which can only happen if all sides represent themselves in the open where debate and resolution take place. Handed over to us instead of won through a difficult, bloody struggle, perhaps our local control came too easily for many to grasp its precious value. Easy come. Easy Go.
Beverly A. De Witt-Moylan, Los Osos UPDATE: (5/11) And Beverly notes . . . Being a California Girl, although married to a Boston Boy, I was aware of the tradition of New England town hall meetingS, as well as the annual big Town Meeting, but, like the Tribune, I didn’t catch the distinction (and had no idea the letter had been changed slightly by the Tribune editors.) A little history lesson for us all. The following excerpt from Bev’s email:
Dear Ann,
As long as you have posted my PUBLISHED letter to the editor, you might as well have THE REST OF THE STORY which I sent out today. Since I've already had my say for this month, and since they don't like printing criticism of themselves, this won't get into the TRIB, but people who like to argue on your web site might get something out of it. Use it or not... . . .
Blessings of peace,
Bev.
----- Original Message -----
From: MOYLANS
To: letters@thetribunenews.com
Sent: Wednesday, May 10, 2006 7:27 AM
Subject: correction
Thank you for printing my letter regarding dissolution of the Los Osos CSD in its entirety in the Tuesday issue. After my careful effort to hone it to 200 words, it was somewhat surprising to read the first sentence, which you edited by adding two letters to its length. "Town Meeting was," in your hands became, "town meetings were." While I am aware that few people outside New England would have any understanding of Town Meeting as an institution, it might have been instructive to trust that your readers would understand the term in context. Like anywhere else in the USA, meetings are held year round in my hometown. They are not, however, town meetings. They are Board of Selectmen (a term which has survived since colonial times) meetings, which citizens attend in the same way as they attend city council or CSD meetings in this county.
Town Meeting is a specific process, described in my previous letter to you, which happens every spring in those New England towns where it has survived. In my home town of Canton, Massachusetts, Town Meeting occurred in March when I was growing up. It is a proper noun, such as, "Are you going to Town Meeting?" or "Town Meeting begins at 7 PM."
Rather than changing my words to suit your paradigm, it might have been prudent to discover whether the specific phrasing used had merit and meaning. Though probably borne from innocent provincialism, it is insulting to be treated like an ignorant bumpkin by your presumption that I meant something I did not. Judging from the Trib's coverage of the RWQCB CDO prosecution hearings, however, it is not surprising. Your paradigm regarding citizens of Los Osos would not allow you to see it any other way.
Beverley De Witt-Moylan, B.A., M.Ed.
Los Osos
The following letter-to-the-editor appeared in the Tribune May 9th by Beverly A. De Witt-Moylan of Los Osos (She’s one of the Los Osos 45 served with a CDO) Her letter speaks to something that I found fascinating here in Sewerville: How quickly certain folks moved to dissolve the CSD that many of them, ironically, had struggled so hard to create in the first place when a recall didn’t go their way. No town meetings for them, no open debates, no compromise, no new candidates, no input or even new initiatives, no working on committees, no re-recalls (wouldn't that have been fun?), no use of any of the tools in the “democratic” tool chest except --- Blam! -- out of the box – dissolve the whole CSD. End game. No ninth-grade civics for them. Nosir!
It remains one of the most fascinating elements of this whole strange trip. Clearly, Sewervillers ain’t New Englanders, more’s the pity.
Growing up in New England, town meetings were a way of life for me.
Every week in March, my parents met our neighbors at the Town Hall to debate and vote on the town budget for the year. Into the night they amended and revised our local bylaws, item by item, with the Board of Selectmen, our town’s governing body.
This purest form of democracy continues to thrive in many communities across the Northeast. Though some have joked that we threw off the bonds of England only to be free to tax ourselves, the representative democracy that emerged from the American Revolution is the best embodiment of the concept in the world today.
Anyone who benefits from self-governance has a stake in democracy. Having only recently gained the right to local control, Los Osos struggles now with forces working to solve local problems by dissolving local government.
Ninth-grade civics teaches that the foundation of democracy is compromise, which can only happen if all sides represent themselves in the open where debate and resolution take place. Handed over to us instead of won through a difficult, bloody struggle, perhaps our local control came too easily for many to grasp its precious value. Easy come. Easy Go.
Beverly A. De Witt-Moylan, Los Osos UPDATE: (5/11) And Beverly notes . . . Being a California Girl, although married to a Boston Boy, I was aware of the tradition of New England town hall meetingS, as well as the annual big Town Meeting, but, like the Tribune, I didn’t catch the distinction (and had no idea the letter had been changed slightly by the Tribune editors.) A little history lesson for us all. The following excerpt from Bev’s email:
Dear Ann,
As long as you have posted my PUBLISHED letter to the editor, you might as well have THE REST OF THE STORY which I sent out today. Since I've already had my say for this month, and since they don't like printing criticism of themselves, this won't get into the TRIB, but people who like to argue on your web site might get something out of it. Use it or not... . . .
Blessings of peace,
Bev.
----- Original Message -----
From: MOYLANS
To: letters@thetribunenews.com
Sent: Wednesday, May 10, 2006 7:27 AM
Subject: correction
Thank you for printing my letter regarding dissolution of the Los Osos CSD in its entirety in the Tuesday issue. After my careful effort to hone it to 200 words, it was somewhat surprising to read the first sentence, which you edited by adding two letters to its length. "Town Meeting was," in your hands became, "town meetings were." While I am aware that few people outside New England would have any understanding of Town Meeting as an institution, it might have been instructive to trust that your readers would understand the term in context. Like anywhere else in the USA, meetings are held year round in my hometown. They are not, however, town meetings. They are Board of Selectmen (a term which has survived since colonial times) meetings, which citizens attend in the same way as they attend city council or CSD meetings in this county.
Town Meeting is a specific process, described in my previous letter to you, which happens every spring in those New England towns where it has survived. In my home town of Canton, Massachusetts, Town Meeting occurred in March when I was growing up. It is a proper noun, such as, "Are you going to Town Meeting?" or "Town Meeting begins at 7 PM."
Rather than changing my words to suit your paradigm, it might have been prudent to discover whether the specific phrasing used had merit and meaning. Though probably borne from innocent provincialism, it is insulting to be treated like an ignorant bumpkin by your presumption that I meant something I did not. Judging from the Trib's coverage of the RWQCB CDO prosecution hearings, however, it is not surprising. Your paradigm regarding citizens of Los Osos would not allow you to see it any other way.
Beverley De Witt-Moylan, B.A., M.Ed.
Los Osos
Tuesday, May 09, 2006
Press Release from the LOCSD
(for immediate release)
WATER BOARD CANCELS HEARING FOR LOS OSOS Citizen CDO’s
(Cease and Desist Orders)
NEW LEGAL COUNSEL for Prosecution Team TO BE OBTAINED
The latest twist in the long-fought battle between the Regional Water Quality Control Board and the 4500+ septic tank owners of Los Osos occurred late Friday afternoon when the Water Board announced that proceedings to issue Cease and Desist Orders to the first wave of 45 septic tank owners in Los Osos will be halted mid-stream, to allow the Water Board’s Prosecution Team to obtain new legal counsel. Such announcement comes on the heels of a vehement argument raised by the Los Osos Community Services District’s lawyers at the start of the hearings that the proceedings were tainted because two of the Water Board’s key advisors, attorney Lori Okun and Executive Officer Roger Briggs, were also key members of the Prosecution Team. The District’s lawyers moved to dismiss the proceedings, alleging that such practice was unconstitutional and resulted in a biased and unfair hearing. The District’s motion was denied at the Friday hearing, which continued from 10 am -10 pm and was to be continued on May 11-12.
But in a letter dated May 4, the Prosecution Team requested that the Water Board put a halt to proceedings to allow the Prosecution Team to obtain new legal counsel. On Friday, the Water Board granted that request and set a meeting for May 11 at 10 am at Water Board headquarters in San Luis Obispo to discuss what to do next.
When asked about the ruling, District lead counsel Stephen Onstot stated “it’s a good start, but doesn’t go far enough. The Prosecution Team already presented its case, so the damage has already been done. You can’t un-ring the bell. Mr. Briggs advises the Board as well and he, too, should be disqualified from being a prosecutor. The law is also clear that the Water Board members who heard Ms. Okun’s and Mr. Briggs’ prosecution case must now recuse themselves from participating in deliberations on whether to issue the Cease and Desist Orders.” If that is the case, the Water Board would be put in a difficult position, for it would not have enough eligible members to constitute the quorum necessary to proceed against the septic tank owners. END
Well, there’s a few new wrinkles. Replace the whole Board for this trial? Import new Board members? Move the trial to Kettleman City? Have 4,500 homeowners trek down Highway 46 aka “Blood Alley” for 12-hour hearings? Yikes.
Plus, I hate to keep sticking it to the Tribune but this one’s a true puzzle. The ruling pertains to the creation of a new state Office of Enforcement and there’s not a word about it in the Tribune. Clearly, the structure of the RWQCB is such that it inadvertently created this problem of bias with no independent checks or balances, a system that has been in force yet out of balance for years. And this is a statewide problem that could have wide-ranging consequences (are old cases going to be appealed? retried? thrown out? What??), yet there’s nary a peep out of the Tribune about any of this. The little blurb they did run made it sound like this was simply a minor, local matter arising only out of the recent CDOs, a matter that could be quickly settled so the whole mad CDO scheme could move rapidly forward. From this press release, there may be even more trouble ahead, even if The Grand Inquisitor General does ride into town. For example, there’s the little matter of GIGO. Unless the Grand Inquisitor General is also an expert soil scientist and expert in all things septic, he won’t know that the information the local staff is giving him may be fatally flawed, so the whole cockamamie thing could collapse in a heap when it winds its way through the “administrative” type hearings and lands in a “real” court of law. Then there’s the matter of . . . Roger Briggs. What ever shall we do about Roger?
Once again, what can I say except, It’s Sewerville. Stay tuned.
(for immediate release)
WATER BOARD CANCELS HEARING FOR LOS OSOS Citizen CDO’s
(Cease and Desist Orders)
NEW LEGAL COUNSEL for Prosecution Team TO BE OBTAINED
The latest twist in the long-fought battle between the Regional Water Quality Control Board and the 4500+ septic tank owners of Los Osos occurred late Friday afternoon when the Water Board announced that proceedings to issue Cease and Desist Orders to the first wave of 45 septic tank owners in Los Osos will be halted mid-stream, to allow the Water Board’s Prosecution Team to obtain new legal counsel. Such announcement comes on the heels of a vehement argument raised by the Los Osos Community Services District’s lawyers at the start of the hearings that the proceedings were tainted because two of the Water Board’s key advisors, attorney Lori Okun and Executive Officer Roger Briggs, were also key members of the Prosecution Team. The District’s lawyers moved to dismiss the proceedings, alleging that such practice was unconstitutional and resulted in a biased and unfair hearing. The District’s motion was denied at the Friday hearing, which continued from 10 am -10 pm and was to be continued on May 11-12.
But in a letter dated May 4, the Prosecution Team requested that the Water Board put a halt to proceedings to allow the Prosecution Team to obtain new legal counsel. On Friday, the Water Board granted that request and set a meeting for May 11 at 10 am at Water Board headquarters in San Luis Obispo to discuss what to do next.
When asked about the ruling, District lead counsel Stephen Onstot stated “it’s a good start, but doesn’t go far enough. The Prosecution Team already presented its case, so the damage has already been done. You can’t un-ring the bell. Mr. Briggs advises the Board as well and he, too, should be disqualified from being a prosecutor. The law is also clear that the Water Board members who heard Ms. Okun’s and Mr. Briggs’ prosecution case must now recuse themselves from participating in deliberations on whether to issue the Cease and Desist Orders.” If that is the case, the Water Board would be put in a difficult position, for it would not have enough eligible members to constitute the quorum necessary to proceed against the septic tank owners. END
Well, there’s a few new wrinkles. Replace the whole Board for this trial? Import new Board members? Move the trial to Kettleman City? Have 4,500 homeowners trek down Highway 46 aka “Blood Alley” for 12-hour hearings? Yikes.
Plus, I hate to keep sticking it to the Tribune but this one’s a true puzzle. The ruling pertains to the creation of a new state Office of Enforcement and there’s not a word about it in the Tribune. Clearly, the structure of the RWQCB is such that it inadvertently created this problem of bias with no independent checks or balances, a system that has been in force yet out of balance for years. And this is a statewide problem that could have wide-ranging consequences (are old cases going to be appealed? retried? thrown out? What??), yet there’s nary a peep out of the Tribune about any of this. The little blurb they did run made it sound like this was simply a minor, local matter arising only out of the recent CDOs, a matter that could be quickly settled so the whole mad CDO scheme could move rapidly forward. From this press release, there may be even more trouble ahead, even if The Grand Inquisitor General does ride into town. For example, there’s the little matter of GIGO. Unless the Grand Inquisitor General is also an expert soil scientist and expert in all things septic, he won’t know that the information the local staff is giving him may be fatally flawed, so the whole cockamamie thing could collapse in a heap when it winds its way through the “administrative” type hearings and lands in a “real” court of law. Then there’s the matter of . . . Roger Briggs. What ever shall we do about Roger?
Once again, what can I say except, It’s Sewerville. Stay tuned.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)