Pages

Friday, May 26, 2006

Are Those Domain Names In Your Pocket, Or Are You Just Glad To See Me?

Mother Calhoun is getting downright discouraged. She thought that through the years, people were actually paying attention to her Sage Advice For The Clueless. But clearly, nobody’s listening because there are people out there still Walking While Stupid.

I refer, of course, to the May 24th Bay News story, “Taxpayer’s Watch Decries Internet Skullduggery,” wherein we learn that back on Nov 29, 2005, CSD Interim Counsel John McClendon bought up several web addresses for $2.99 each. The web addresses he bought were variations on all things taxpayerswatch-ish, such as www.Taxpayerswatch.org and www.Taxpayerswatch.com and so forth. McClendon, no doubt with his tongue thoroughly set in his cheek, is quoted in the story as saying that he did his shopping “on his own time and paid the fees. He said he has nothing against the local Taxpayers Watch, but makes it a practice to pick up web addresses that may benefit future clients. He said there are Taxpayers Watch organizations in several communities. ‘I was depressed that night,’ he explained, ‘I went shopping and I’m Scottish. I’m cheap. I love a bargain.’”

So, what’s the problem here? People buy domain names all the time. No big deal, right? Well, to continue the Bay News story, “[McClendon] said he ‘parked’ the addresses to send people to the CSD site [instead]. He also indicated he was sorry that the CSD was being rapped’ for his actions.” In other words, when people typed in the domain names he owned, thinking they were going to the Taxpayerswatch site, they would be bounced over the official CSD site instead. Very funny?

Gee, you think?

Naturally, Joyce Albright, chairwoman for the local Taxpayers Watch group, jumped to the conclusion that this was all the responsibility of the CSD. Said she, “It’s just proof again of the methods of the current board. It’s duplicitous, underhanded and sneaky. I’m shocked at the low quality people they employ.” Which caused many people familiar with the published product and actions of Taxpayers Watch to roll their eyes and mutter, “Pots & Kettles, Pots & Kettles.”

Then, after being shocked – shocked – Joyce was quoted as saying that “As a result, the web address for Taxpayers Watch has been changed to: dissolvethelocalcad.org. Even though she was irked, Albright said the change did not cost them any money or cause them to do extra work. ‘I like the new one better,’ she said. ‘It says it all.’”

So, no harm, no foul? Really? Well, listen up everyone. Mother Calhoun will – once again – spell it out for you:

1. When you know a group of people have declared themselves to be your sworn enemy, hell-bent on destroying you utterly, and they have already proven to you that they have a shaky grasp on the difference between “fact” and Madison Avenue’s distorted version of Phony Phacts, and have no ethical compunction against employing such duplicitous, underhanded and sneaky tactics in all they do and say, you do not give them swords.

2. Perception IS reality. Public servants, working on the taxpayer’s dime, have a special duty to be like Casesar’s Wife: Not only do they have to be above suspicion, they must appear to be above suspicion.

3. Private citizens are free to lie, distort, play dirty tricks on one another and engage in other assorted japery. Public servants are not. I know. Unfair double standard. Tough. Deal with it.

On a happier note, the Bay News story did reveal, ta-DA- “According to documentation provided by McClendon, the Taxpayers Watch’s current Web site address – which he [McClendon] characterized as the ‘I’m still mad’ Web site – is owned by Michael Drake, the former CSD public information officer who was fired after the recall election.”

Mikeee’s baaaack!

Yep, the same Mike who was quoted using the word “we” as in “WE’VE been waiting THIRTY YEARS for this sewer plant,” & etc. when, in truth, he’d only arrived in town a few months before. And, I’m not sure the word “fired” is exactly accurate. “Fired” almost always has negative connotations – i.e. that the person in question is incompetent or had been discovered engaging in some sort of skullduggery. Mike’s contract as Public Information Officer was specifically tied to the Tri-W sewer project. No project, no contract. No contract, no Mike. So, unless something was uncovered during the new CSD’s Board during closed session discussions, it may be fairer to say Mike’s contract was terminated rather than he was “fired.”

Of course, during his tenure, there were many complaints that Mike had crossed the line between Public Information and political advocacy during the recall campaign. But here he is again, working with Joyce Albright and [recalled board member] Gordon Hensley and other supporters, members and associates of Taxpayers Watch. Ah, the old gang, back together again! What could be better?

The only question left is this: Who’s writing the Phacts that appear on Mr. Drake’s Taxpayer’s Watch website?

Thursday, May 25, 2006

Calhoun’s Cannons, The Bay News, Morro Bay, CA, for May 24, 06


Yin & Yang


Help thy brother’s boat across and Lo! thine own has reached the shore.
Hindu proverb


Ron Crawford, former Bay News editor, has maintained a blog at http://www.sewerwatch.blogspot.com/ and has recently posted a stunning piece of blog theatre, titled “Contrast.”. If you ever wanted to know what some of your neighbors thought of you and moved heaven and earth to attempt to get rained down on your heads, do log on and take a gander at the nice selection of crunch and bite that Ron’s assembled for you. Selected readings for your contemplation. Bon appetite!

At my own blogsite (http://www.calhounscannon.blogspot.com/), a dedicated band of Sewergeeks have turned the Comment section into something akin to the old country store, with folks gathered around the internet’s version of the pot-bellied stove to yak and natter. But we were all brought up short by an anonymous cri de coeur posted by someone called “CDOer.”

Whether through denial (it won’t happen to me), or ignorance (what’s a CDO?), or fantasy (dissolution and “The County” will save me -- Wrong, it won’t, and the County refused to help you, even as an “Interested Party”), or apathy (I’ll think about that tomorrow), 45 of your friends and neighbors who have been randomly targeted for political punishment using Cease & Desist Orders by an incompetent, inappropriately emotionalized, ill-prepared, out-of-control Regional Water Quality Control Board, have spent months doing the heavy lifting for the whole community – that’s you, dear and gentle reader. “CDOer” had a few things to say to my blog kibitzers that bears repeating in this column. Please pay attention: The shoes this writer is walking in are your shoes.

“If I were a Zen master, I would whack you between the shoulder blades to bring you into the present and out of the daydream that prevents you from addressing the issues in front of your face.

“[when the 45 CDOs were issued] . . . You and every other citizen in Los Osos had the opportunity to request Interested Party status from the RWQCB in the matter of the CDOs. Designated Parties [The Los Osos 45] and Interested Parties have been meeting every week for months to invent the wheel, educating ourselves and supporting each other, as well as reaching out to the community with information and to ask for support. Remember the door hanger you got just before the [April 28 ] hearing? We who have much better things to do distributed 5,000 of those on foot [and], by hand.

“Had you been attending those meetings, you would know what Los Osos can do right now. As it is, everyone who comes after us with their own CDO will have to re-invent the wheel or beg us to please assist them, and we are so tired. You won’t know how tired that is until you have had your CDO for three months, [attended] meetings, research[ed] hundreds of pages of documents, walk[ed] door-to-door to 5,000 [Prohibition zone] homes, [spent time] writing legislators, writing objections . . . writing briefs.

“What can Los Osos do RIGHT NOW? Attend every meeting you can find – CSD meetings and sub-committee meetings. PARTICIPATE. . . .Los Osos has too many citizens sniping from the shadows. . . . Stay out of the back door. Walk in the front door. Show you face. Have the guts to attach your name to it and face those you disagree with. . . . Find out who your CDO neighbors are. Attend any community meetings you can find . . . Contact the [CSD] board members. . . . Try engaging instead of confronting. . . . And most importantly of all, start educating yourself for [your] CDO days to come.”

Right now, the CSD is in the process of formulating a Septic System Management Program that can offer to the RWQCB more effective interim mitigation options than the wrongly applied CDO plan calls for. A SSMP is a program that the RWQCB and the County have failed to implement for 20 years. But only the CSD and informed and engaged citizens of Los Osos can now finally make that happen.

Another informational meeting for the Los Osos 45 is planned for 7 p.m. on June 12 at Sunnyside School. For further information, call Rob Shipe at 528-6772 or Bill Moylan at 528-2324.

In all matters Sewerish, CDOish, and SSMPish, getting actively and openly involved in helping your friends and neighbors isn’t altruism. It’s pure enlightened self interest.

Sunday, May 21, 2006

Options First, Trial Later? Is that County Mummy Dearest I see standing there suddenly, all smiles and huggie-boos?


First, a May 12 letter to CSD General Manager, Dan Bleskey and Gail Wilcox, Assistant County Administrator, from Paul Hood, Executive Officer of LAFCO. This will be followed by my Nosey Parker Public Comment. And following that, a deliciously accurate recipe by Gail McPherson on just how one goes about dissolving a CSD.

The biggest puzzle to me in what appears to be Mr. Hood’s trial balloon proposal, besides it being curiously cart before horse-ish, is this: Why is the county being asked to play the role of the loving parent . . . now? I mean, the county was free to step up to “joint-partner” while the Great Blakeslee Compromise negotiations were underway. Indeed, they were free to “joint-partner” with various financing options even after the Blakeslee Compromise fell through, yet they said nothing. And when asked to sign on as either a Designated Party or an Interested Party for the CDO’s, their response was Talk To The Hand.

So far as I know, the only “county” response to the CSD efforts to move the sewer came in the form of an Oct 20th letter from Supervisor Shirley Bianchi to State Water Board Chair Arthur Baggett assuring him that “This is a particularly difficult situation since the current District Board either will not or cannot understand any government process. At one point I was asked if the political will exists here in San Luis Obispo County to assume the management of the project [Tri-W] if, for whatever reason, the District were unable to continue with it. Let me assure you that you have my full support, and I believe that the other Supervisors would give great weight to my position.”

In other words, screw the voters and since the newly elected CSD Board was too stupid to “understand any governmental process,” then they certainly weren’t an elected body that needed to be treated as a co-equal governing body. No, indeed. Instead, Mummy Bianchi could be relied on to go behind their backs and take matters into her (and Water Board Chair Baggett’s) own hands.

Oh, did I forget to tell you, Supervisor Bianchi is one of the LAFCO Commissioners, and to my knowledge, she has not excused herself from voting on the dissolution of The Good Old Too Stupid To “Understand Any Governmental Process” Los Osos CSD. Ah, yes, unbiased Mummy Dearest Redux.

So, pass the cheese, please. I smell something cooking here. Rats en brochette, perhaps? Which is why I have to wonder if The County now loves Los Osos ---like a glutton loves his lunch?


LAFCO’s letter:

Subject: Collaborative Options to Dissolving the District

Dear Mr. Bleskey and Ms. Wilcox:

As you know, a proposal to dissolve the Los Osos community Services District has been filed with the Local Agency Formation Commission (LAFCO). LAFCO staff is in the process of evaluating several different options regarding the Dissolution proposal. In analyzing this application, two options have been identified that would call for the cooperation of both the County and the District. These collaborative options could help resolve the situation if the County and District are willing to work together. The options are described as follows:

Option A: Divesture of the Sewer Power from the District. The LOCSD would voluntarily divest itself of the power to provide wastewater and sewer services and the County would voluntarily agree to provide this service. LAFCO approval of this action is required for this option to be implemented.

Discussion. If the District chose to divest the sewer power, they would continue to provide other services to the community of Los Osos; i.e. water, fire, street lighting, garbage, etc. The District would remain as the local agency that provides services to the community and may be able to manage the sewer at some point in the future, subject to LAFCO approval. The sewer power could be transferred to the County through the activation of this power under County Service Area 9. The County would not be obligated to assume the responsibility for the other services. The County appears to be in a better position in terms of resources and financial standing to complete the sewer project. Moreover, this action could be conditioned by LAFCO to limit the liability that would be transferred to the County. Current liabilities, loans, bonds and lawsuits would remain with the District because the CSD still exists, subject to LAFCO conditions for the divestiture as permitted by statute.

Option B: County and District enter into a Joint Powers Agreement. This option would give the LOCSD and the County the opportunity to develop an agreement that would create a “Board” or “Authority” to construct and operate the sewer. The County and District could work out the details of such an agreement that may limit liability and increase the chances that the sewer would be constructed in a timely and more cost effective manner. LAFCO approval of this action is not required for this option.

Discussion: A Joint Powers Agreement (JPA) would create a new governmental structure that may be able to obtain financing at a reasonable interest rate while limiting the liability to the County and the District. Through the Joint Exercise of Powers Act public, agencies may agree to assist one another using a Joint Powers Agreement that establishes a board, commission other agency to provide governance for the project. A joint Powers Agreement identifies roles and responsibilities for the agency. Under Government Code 6546, revenue bonds may be issued by the joint powers entity for the construction of wastewater facilities (6546(g)). It may be possible for a Joint Powers Agreement to be written contractually in such a manner as to limit the liability that might be incurred by the County or the District. The precise details of the JPA would be addressed if the County and the District decide to enter into such an Agreement.

LAFCO is interested in hearing from the District and the County with regard to the potential and feasibility of the above options. These options provide a way to work together to complete the sewer project in a manner that could be more cost effective and time efficient. It may be that after the sewer project is completed the facilities are transferred to the District for operation and maintenance.

We will be including a discussion of these options in the June 15, 1006 Staff Report to the Commission. An immediate response from the District and County regarding these alternatives would be helpful. If you wish the Commission to consider your input on these options, please provide a written response by May 22, 1006.

Thank you for your assistance in this matter. Please don’t hesitate to call me at 805-781-5795 if you have any questions.

Sincerely,


[Paul Hood]



And My Nosey Parker Public Comment to Mr. Hood’s letter

May 19, 2006

Paul Hood, Exec. Director
LAFCO
Commissioners & Staff
County Courthouse Complex, Admin
1042 Pacific St. Suite A
San Luis Obispo, CA 93402


Dear Mr. Hood,

I wish the Commission and all interested parties to consider this my public input on your May 12 letter re the Collaborative Options to Dissolving the District:

Your May 19 letter offers two options to resolve the question of Dissolving the CSD. I’m afraid I’m missing something. Aren’t there four or more options? 1) deny the dissolution petition for lack of substantiated and sufficient grounds to shut down a functioning CSD; 2) substantiate all the charges as sufficient reason for dissolving a functioning CSD; 3) Separate certain functions, i.e.”sewer power;” and 4) some alternative joint power or lead agency or some other negotiated and voter approved system; 5) some other option.

Since what LAFCO decides must be based on criteria that applies to all past, present, and future CSDs equally, I am deeply concerned that “options” are premature at this stage, and would caution that the LAFCO board needs to seriously think about precedent here.

It is no secret that a certain group of individuals wanted a particular type of sewer plant in the middle of town and when the community disagreed with that, these folks moved immediately to dissolve the CSD in hope that The County would immediately re-start a particular type of sewer plant in the middle of town. That they used LAFCO as a political tool to accomplish this one particular goal should give everyone involved with this matter cause for concern. The criteria for dissolving a functioning CSD needs to be based on solid, neutral ground, not political pique or hidden agendas.

So far as I know, the judge who has ordered an audit of the CSD’s books still hasn’t assigned an auditor to complete that task. In her March 24 letter, Gail Wilcox notes that before she can make a recommendation to the BoS “we would need further reliable information as to the true state of affairs at LOCSD.” . . . including various real and actual liabilities (not made up un-hatched chickens) and so forth. If you don’t have information from the audit yet, isn’t a “collaborative option” premature? If you don’t yet have accurate information, (and in the various contractual mediations, things can change quickly, one way or the other), I would strongly suggest, as Ms. Wilcox suggests in her March 24 letter, “that LAFCO take advantage of the provisions of Government Code section 56666, which allows for up to a 70 day continuance of the hearing.”

In Option A, of your May 12 letter, you state, “The county appears to be in a better position in terms of resources and financial standing to complete the sewer project.” THE sewer project? What sewer project? The CSD is now in the middle of a process of updating the wastewater report and depending on what the report says, THEN they’ll know what kind of project will be the preferred one to be presented to the community. Right now, there is nothing that can be called “The” project, unless, of course, you are referring to The [old] Tri-W Project?

In Option B, you again state that “an agreement that would create a “Board” or “Authority” to construct and operate the sewer.” THE sewer? Again, what project are you talking about?

In Option A, you note that divesting the sewer power would be done only if the action “could be conditioned by LAFCO to limit the liability that would be transferred to the County. Current liabilities, loans, bonds and lawsuits would remain with the District [emphasis mine] because the CSD still exists . . . . . .” while Option B notes that the Joint Powers Agreement would “be written contractually in such a manner as to limit the liability that might be incurred by the County or the district.” [emphasis mine.]

Why would Option A stick the district with all liabilities while Option B somehow limits that same District liability?

Option A notes that “The LOCSD would voluntarily divest itself . . .” while Option B says nothing about “voluntarily” entering a joint powers agreement. In presenting the options here, at this time, before the hearings even take place, are you really presenting the community with Hobson’s Choice? i.e. choose one of these options NOW, or else we will go ahead and vote to dissolve the entire CSD?

If that’s what’s really at work here, then shouldn’t LAFCO first offer the full case for dissolution on June 15 (if the proper audited financial information is in hand by then), with full opportunity to rebut their case, and only then suggest or offer options before or as part of a final recommendation?

Once again, I have serious concerns that what LAFCO may be considering must be done in such a way so as not to set an awful precedent – that of using LAFCO as a partisan political tool when the ballot box fails one particular group or another.

Sincerely,

Ann Calhoun


And now, on a lighter note. Some delicious thoughts to munch on by Gail McPherson. What the Irish call “joking on the square.” Or is it? [copy edited for blog posting with permission of author]



While the [recall] vote represented a rejection of the project at Tri W and the lack of acceptance of the exceedingly high cost of the sewer project, and lack of confidence in the [old] board majority, what would it take for the ousted board and a handful of spiteful supporters to dissolve the CSD and regain power?

Lost Credibility, Lawsuits, Claims and Debt, Frozen Funds/ Bankruptcy, and Individual Fines….That and more are the necessary in”greed”ients for a Taxpayers’ Watch Dissolution Recipe. Herewith a 10 point plan of how it works: (keep in mind that a CSD Success spells Failure to Albright and her ousted cronies)

You must ensure the CSD is embroiled in lawsuits and controversy from the first day they are sworn into office. Taxpayers’ Watch (formed from those who lost the election) filed the first of numerous lawsuits the day after the election, before the first ‘post recall’ CSD meeting.
Assure cooperation by Briggs and the Water Board to fine the CSD into bankruptcy. Public records documents between Briggs and members of Taxpayers’ Watch confirm they lobbied and got the Water Board to draft actions for $11 million in fines and individual CDOs as the election was being certified.
Stop the Funds -Assure a preemptive strike by contacting the SWRCB and informing them the board is thumbing their nose at the State and flaunting “they will never pay you back.” Use the 218 requirement to confirm CSD intentions. Request SWRCB pull funds and default on the contract, before speaking to the “lawfully elected lead agency” because they “know nothing about government.”

Project funding that could be reassigned to a project out of town must be aborted: The CSD had the authority to revise the project and the loan with SWRCB approval. Lobbying before the recall election would convince the SWRCB not to listen to the public outcry against the [Tri-W] project, which gave the SWRCB confidence that if they played ball with the old CSD the recall would fail and Voila! an unwanted sewer project would be funded and built.
Stop Negotiations to preserve funding and forward motion on the project. Torpedo-Blakeslee’s compromise-. A lower cost plant out of town was presented, and several parcels were identified. The CSD would be building now, No fines, No default, No lawyer’s fees. NO DISSOLUTION?? This recipe can’t let that happen!
Minimization and usurping lawful authority: Lobbying efforts to assure the SWRCB would NEVER recognize the new CSD as the lawfully elected LEAD agency for negotiations. Launch and maintain huge lobbying efforts to forever etch “anti-sewer-obstructionists” and Los Osos crazies into the SWRCB collective mind.
Announce dissolution and make promises that once the County takes over, there would be no claims or debt, no CSD fines, resumed low interest funding, agency “respect’ and peace will return to the people’s lives. Keep repeating “the recall was close, and not everyone voted”...get the fear factor with headlines about fines and loan default working and go gather signatures. Promise anything…dreamers never delivered on a single promise before except to promise that the CSD would be annihilated if they lost the election!
Anti Sewer Perception, Board is unqualified, inept and naive: Media and public agencies must never view the new board as being capable, (current board is made up of scientists, engineers, planners-all 5 with extensive government experience)
The CSD must never be perceived as in favor of a wastewater project, or capable of delivering one. Assign the 30 years of delays to them as well as millions in wasted public funds.
File more lawsuits against each one, and then claim it’s a waste of public funds to use attorneys to defend the district-as required by law.
Litigation must erode both the public funds and the confidence of the public.
Ratchet up the expenditures for required District legal defenses and then publicly announce the huge waste.
Make up the numbers, a few million on the construction claims, more on litigation. No one will stop to imagine it all can be tracked back to actions by the recalled board before the election to assure this very outcome.
Hide that the ousted Board had active litigation against agencies and individuals, before the election, which the new CSD fiduciary duty required and obligated them to settle at the lowest cost to taxpayers.
Exploit that positive settlement as wasteful and file another lawsuit for waste. Hide this CSD’s lack of fiduciary responsibility. Taxpayers’ Watch will grab the settled Measure B lawsuit, and drive up the cost again.
Keep the media and press focused to assure the perception by the courts and public is the CSD is “anti sewer” and then drum beat the rumor that the CSD was paying “friends” with settlement money.
Claims settled and debt reorganized stops bankruptcy. Freeze CSD funds so the board can’t defend the district against Taxpayers’ Watch myriad lawsuits. Better, assure they can’t deliver a project, settle claims or reorganize debt. How? Get the contractors who worked hand in glove with Taxpayers’ Watch to torpedo the compromise, to lobby the SWRCB and RWQCB against working with the CSD. (Also, do hide their substantial campaign contributions to help the old Board and hope nobody notices). Best of all, the contractors’ loyalty to the old board will be promised payments in the form of full claim recovery. Millions to the contractors, on a bid 45% over estimates, on contracts front loaded to drive up the debt. Yes, millions instead of the pennies on the dollar they’d get in a CSD settlement with the new Board. Reason enough for a Dissolution Recipe. Dinner is served.

Tuesday, May 16, 2006

Whose Ethics?

The following is a formal letter of complaint from LOCSD Board Chairperson Lisa Schicker. A few caveats are in order:

First, formal letters of complaint are like lawsuits; Both can be full of allegations that may or may not be true, so Caveat lector.

That said, this complaint does raise some interesting questions:

First, violations of state law and/or contract violations are clear: They either occurred or they didn’t, and as such need to be investigated by the proper authorities – in the case of state law, the DA needs to be involved; contract violations will require a hearing in a civil court, no doubt.

So, that leaves “ethics,” an interesting grey area the raises some questions. For example, as a professional independent contractor/consultant, who does MWH work for and answer to? Themselves? A Board Majority (3 votes)? The General Manager? The citizens whose tax/service-fee dollars are paying their bills? To whom, then does the consultant owe their due diligence, best ethical and professional practices, and fiduciary duty?

Since elected boards are, in almost all cases, “amateurs,” (if they weren’t, they would have no need of professional services by outside consultants), they are always at a disadvantage. How are they to know, for example, if their consultant is truthful, fair, objective, and is rendering the best possible service to the community? Does the consultant have an ethical duty to speak truth to power? Or is the consultant behaving like an unethical used car salesman and adding all kinds of unnecessary bells and whistles onto a project in order to jack their fees? Who, in short, has the knowledge and expertise to watch the consultant? And if a Board shuts down citizen advisory committees, thereby limiting a variety of “public eyes on the page,” . . . . and refuses to listen to and take seriously public input regarding contracts or costs and so forth . . . . ?

And if a consultant violates all manner of professional and ethical behavior and/or legal matters, thereby sticking taxpayers with excessive fees and costs, for example, who has the responsibility to see to it that legal remedies are applied? Individual citizens? The CSD Board? Right now, the CSD is in contractual/arbitration-type “discussions” with MWH, that may or may not resolve these issues and may or may not result in a satisfactory outcome, or may end up in court. But, if the CSD itself is dissolved, will legal remedies be left up to individual citizens? Will the County take over the matter or simply let it drop, thereby leaving the residents to forever wonder if they have been stuck with paying unnecessary? excessive? unethical? illegal? costs?

And, finally, regarding the $10,000 MWH contributed to the anti-recall effort, if MWH’s client was the community (certainly all property owners within the prohibition zone who were going to pay for this project, thereby paying MWH’s salaries), could it ever be considered ethical for such a firm to use what is, in reality, the citizens’ own money to get involved in any way in what was clearly a partisan political dogfight?

As for complaints to professional Associations, it’s been my experience that such Associations that even bother to have Codes of Conduct in the first place, have them as a piece of feel-good, for-public-consumption-only, CYA public relations ploy. When asked to seriously investigate a member, their usual response is, Talk to the hand. Our ethical standards are “voluntary,” and my, isn’t it unfortunate, what a sad world we live in, sigh, perhaps you need to see an attorney, thanks for writing to share your concerns with us, have a nice day.

Which is why God invented lawyers.
The letter:
May 10, 2006


Bruce D'Agostino
Executive Director
Construction Management Association of America
7918 Jones Branch Drive, Ste. 540
McLean, VA 22102


Subject: Formal Complaint Regarding Montgomery watson harza’s Conduct In Managing The LOs Osos Wastewater Project

Dear Mr. D’Agostino:

This letter is submitted as a formal complaint against Montgomery Watson Harza (MWH) regarding their behavior and performance related to the Los Osos Community Services District’s Wastewater Project. We are requesting that the Construction Management Association of America, which MWH is a member, be investigated for their egregious behavior that completely failed their client, the Los Osos Community Services District and the Citizens of Los Osos.

MWH was hired by the District in September 1999 to be the Project Manager for a planned wastewater treatment system in the community of Los Osos, which is serviced by a Community Services District. This initial assignment was a contract for $288,000.

The first project programming step was to develop a Wastewater Facilities Plan, and the District prepared an RFP for this scope. Oswald Engineering was selected for this task in summer 1999 and MWH was the firm that was hired in the fall to manage Oswald’s work. As described below, it is apparent that MWH failed in their oversight of this portion of the work and undermined Oswald’s efforts. It late 1999, less than one year after MWH was hired, MWH succeeded in taking over Oswald’s portion of the work. MWH then completed the Facilities Plan under the terms of Oswald’s original contract, which was amended at least six times for an additional amount paid to MWH exceeding $1.5 million. MWH had replaced Oswald in less than one year. Oswald was working on a ponding project, the scope of which was developed under MWH’s management. The Central Coast Regional Water Quality Control Board (RWQCB) refused to approve the MWH managed ponding design, due to site size limitations. Instead of reworking the ponding system with Oswald or relocating the plant site, MWH assisted the District in removing and suing Oswald. Recent documentation obtained by the District clearly indicates that MWH colluded with RWQCB staff to work against the Oswald design. Furthermore, MWH inappropriately postured itself to take over the preparation of the Facilities Plan from Oswald. This is a clear ethics violation in that MWH not only failed in its responsibilities to objectively evaluate alternatives, but removed oversight controls that have resulted in significant damages to the District and citizens of Los Osos.

MWH completed the Facilities Plan for an entirely different project. The original MWH contract, which was amended at least six more times, raised the MWH’s fees five-fold. MWH’s efforts in recommending against the community preferred system more than doubled the estimated project construction costs. The amendments and the billings are difficult to track, and in some cases not sequential. Subsequent investigation has revealed that MWH overcharged the District and in numerous instances doubled charged the District.

When MWH completed the Project Facilities Plan (Plan), the District issued an RFP that was prepared by MWH, for the design of the project recommended in the MWH Facilities Plan. The Facilities Plan prepared by MWH was clearly biased against any technology that was different from treatment systems previously designed by MWH for other clients. MWH’s selection criteria were grossly skewed towards a specific treatment process. MWH’s failure to objectively and ethically evaluate all available treatment systems, as well as collection systems, significantly increased the project costs to the citizens. MWH failed to openly inform the District and citizens of other options available that would have been to the community’s preferences and been the environmentally preferred option at a significant savings in capital construction and maintenance and operations.

MWH, serving in their role as the Project Manager, should not have competed for the design phase of the project. MWH clearly had a conflict of interest in developing and assisting with the design proposal phase of the project since they competed for the design contract. MWH wrote the language for the design request for proposal. This gave them a significant advantage during the design competition. MWH’s role as the Project Manager and then performing the design was not only inappropriate but clearly denied the District the object oversight of the design that a Project Manager would have provided. Investigations into the design work project clearly indicate that there was a significant amount of design work that required rework. MWH’s role as the Project Manager allowed MWH to cover up these design errors and omissions. MWH clearly violated its fiduciary responsibility to the District and the citizens of Los Osos to assure that payment was only for acceptable quality work. MWH’s breach of this fiduciary duty as the Project Manager was also flawed because as the Project Manager, MWH was not only responsible for the design reviews but also would review all requests for payment by the design firm to make sure the invoices were correct and reasonable. MWH clearly had a conflict of interest and their objectivity in performing these reviews at a minimum does not meet an acceptable level of performance and certainly did not provide an independent review of the design.

MWH competed with DMJM and Corrolla Engineering for the design assignment in mid 2001, and was awarded the contract in 2002. MWH developed the design, prepared bidding documents into three separate construction packages, and issued these documents to the construction community for bid.

MWH then assisted the District in conducting all phases of the pre-construction activity in the capacity as the District’s technical representative. They assisted with and/or prepared the Invitation for Bid, established the contractor prequalification criteria, facilitated the contractor prequalification process, assisted in the bidding process, reviewed the bids, recommended to the District what bids should be accepted, and assisted in the construction contract awards and the Notice(s) to Proceed.

In 2004, MWH advised the District that it was necessary to pre-qualify contractors bidding on the three contract phases. The project consisted of a conventional MBR plant with micro filtration along with two contracts for the installation of a conventional gravity collection system. Although there may be some justification to pre-qualify the treatment plant contractor, there is no justification to pre-qualify the gravity collection system pipeline contractors. MWH sized the pipeline contracts to such a level that it limited the construction bid capability of prospective bidders to only larger firms. The sizing of the pipeline contracts coupled with the extraordinary pre-qualifications of the pipeline contractors clearly limited the ability of small to medium size contractors to bid the gravity collection system. This act by MWH limited bid competition and exposed the District to increased expense due to the limited competition. A similar argument regarding the pre-qualification of the treatment plant contractors also exposed the District to limited bid competition and was a significant factor in the excessively high bids received.

As a result of the stringent pre-qualification criteria drafted by MWH, there was only one bidder on two of the construction contract packages, and two bidders on the third package. The bids received were substantially above the Engineer’s Estimate that had been prepared by MWH (bids were 24% - 57% over the Engineer’s Estimate).

At the bid opening, a MWH representative remarked to at least two of the District Directors (one of them being me) that the project should be re-bid, due to the lack of competition and because the bids were so high above the Engineer’s Estimate. They also made these statements and prepared a report that also strongly recommended that the project should be rebid due to the high bids. This reported was formally presented to the District Board and the Citizens of Los Osos at a District Wastewater committee meeting and at a District business meeting (tapes available.) Mysteriously, only one week later, after MWH was awarded a $7.685 million (sole sourced) amendment to their design contract for construction management services (total MWH contract value was increased to approximately $14 million), MWH then reversed their opinion about rebiding the construction of the project and recommended that all construction contracts be awarded. This resulted in a total project bid price of approximately $128.2M (MWH =$14M; Whitaker = $24.5M; Barnard = $43.5M; Monterey Mechanical = $46.2M). The Engineer’s Estimate was $78.2M (Whitaker = $19.8M; Barnard = $29.1M; Monterey Mechanical = $29.3M).

The cost of construction was $36M more than the Engineer’s Estimate. MWH’s negotiated fee for the construction management services was 18% of the Engineer’s Estimate. MWH’s motivation for accepting the bids was due to the fact that they would be paid more because their sole source construction management contract was based on a percentage of these higher construction bids. MWH did not compete for this lucrative and excessive Construction Management phase of the work. It is interesting to note that given MWH’s sole source construction management contract and the 740 day duration of the contract this would mean that MWH would be billing at a rate of over $10,000 per day for a team of 5 MWH employees.

This brought the project cost for construction to average of over $50,000 per property owner. Other costs not reflected in the $50,000 amount did not include the decommissioning of individual septic tanks and the installation of residential lateral lines, estimated at $2000-$6000 more per household or the construct of over $30 million in deferred capital facilities. Add to that the cost of financing, real estate purchase, and operating cost, and the monthly cost to the property owner is extremely high for a moderate income community, with 5000 households being required to hook up to the sewer. In addition, because of the land constraints (which MWH ignored), plant expansion to accommodate any additional properties outside the project area, also known as the “Prohibition Zone”, would be impossible. This would likely mean that if there was any growth, or if the remaining residences who were not being sewered (approx. 800 more homes) would choose to hook up at a later date, another treatment plant would be needed at significant additional costs.

The current LOCSD Board contends that MWH colluded with the Central Coast Regional Water Quality Control Board staff, staff of the California State Water Resources Control Board and the construction contractors to accelerate the construction contract awards less than a month before a scheduled recall election that would have significant impact on the location of the treatment plant portion of the work. The project funding, in the form of a State Revolving Fund Loan, was good until December 20, 2005; so there was no reason to rush. MWH, despite no contractual provision to do so, issued an illegal “conditional” Notice to Proceed (NTP). The “conditional” NTP was issued prior to the project being funded and contractually required permit being procured. MWH failed to notify the LOCSD that its recommendation to issue a “conditional” NTP which would permit the contractor to incur significant costs, was not provided for in the contract terms, violated contractual prohibition against front loading the contract and violated state and federal laws prohibiting unauthorized commitments.

As one of two of the seated dissenting Board members at the time of issuance of this “conditional” NTP, I personally protested in writing and at public meetings in May-September 2005, alleging such illegality – I was overruled. I also have numerous email correspondences with our past General Manager Bruce Buel and Steve Hyland, MWH engineer, protesting the use of this “Conditional” NTP notice, clearly and unequivocally pointing out that MWH’s actions violated the contract provisions, and State and Federal law.

Both of the minority Board members (one of them being me) were physically barred from one bidder’s conference MWH conducted in February 2005 (tapes available) and two construction kick-off meetings MWH conducted that were held in late July 2005, (photos available). MWH also refused to video tape the construction meetings, although both Directors and members of the public requested this taping.

It is our Board’s opinion that a violation of state law did occur when the District issued this “conditional” Noticed to Proceed (NTP) to the contractors on July 6, 2005. Because this “conditional” NTP allowed the contractors to incur costs, and because the District did not have the funds or the funding authority it needed to cover these incurred costs. It is clear that MWH’s actions wantonly violated State and Federal laws prohibiting unfunded obligations. Furthermore MWH’s actions clearly violated contractual clauses that specifically prohibited the contractors from front loading construction expenditures. It is incredibly ironic that the contract language prohibiting this act was written by MWH.

It is our opinion that a violation of state and federal law did occur when the “conditional” NTP was issued by MWH to the contractors on July 6, 2005. Project funding by the SWRCB Division of Financial Assistance did not obligate the project funding until August 8, 2005, nearly one month after MWH issued the “Conditional Notice to Proceed”. The required Coastal Commission permit and the site grading permit were required prior to the SWRCB funding the project. These permits were approved and the SWRCB funded the project on August 22, 2005.

The mandatory San Luis Obispo County (SLO) grading permit required that the District obtain a site restoration bond prior to the commencement of any and all grading activities. SLO County Public Works required the bond due to the pending recall election and pending voter initiative that could have halted work at the treatment plant site. Because of the County’s bond requirement, the District Board authorized staff to obtain the required grading bond specifically from “Insco Dico”. However, when Insco Dico refused to issue the bond (due to MWH’s failure to disclose the project risks and significant environmental impacts). MWH colluded with Monterey Mechanical, the treatment plant contractor, to arrange an alternate bond that not only covered the restoration of portions of the treatment plant site but also the restoration of the pipeline contractor’s sites. MWH’s action was not allowed under the contract terms and was in direct violation to the District Board’s authorization.

The District did not have the approved Coastal Commission permit (not issued until August 18, 2005) which was the necessary authority to allow the SWRCB to issue the funds (funds were not released until August 22, 2005) from the SRF Loan fund.

In addition to the improper bond and the illegal “conditional NTP”, MWH colluded with two of the three contractors to improperly pay the contractors at least 30 and possible 60 days early. On August 22, 2005, MWH issued an NTP in accordance with the contract documents. On August 28, 2005, the District requested disbursement of the first draw of funds from the SWRCB SRF loan. The first disbursement of SRF loan funds was specifically required to reimburse the District for all pre-design work and establish a construction contingency fund, as required under the terms of the SRF Loan Agreement. MWH was directed by the District Board to immediately draw down the full amount of the first disbursement, $10,968,984 from the SRF loan as authorized in the SRF contract documents. MWH, without cautioning the former District General Manager and in direct violation of the District Board’s direction, only requested an initial disbursement from the SWRCB of $6,486,144, MWH’s collusion with the former General Manager gives the perception that MWH was working with the former General Manager to cause the most financial damage to any newly elected Board, should the recall succeed.

It is worth noting that MWH worked with the contractors to accelerate the construction contractors’ financial commitment to the project in an effort to influence the voter recall election and/or make the outcome of the election a moot point. It was said by District staff, who MWH was advising, that any financial obligations incurred prior to the recall election would make it too costly to “change course”.

On August 24, 2005, two days after the formal NTP, the contractors invoiced the LOCSD for $1.616M. The construction contract has specific requirements that must be met before MWH could recommend approval of the invoices. In an egregious violation of the payment provisions, MWH did not require the contractors to submit the required construction schedules, certified payrolls, a work payment schedule and other mandatory required documents and certifications. Instead of using the contractually provided seven day progress payment review period provided for MWH to review the submitted payment requests, MWH immediately approved the invoice the same day and without any of the required support documentation or payment justification. In light of the recent disclosure of MWH’s $10,000 contribution to the anti-recall effort and the fact that MWH would have financially benefited if termination of the project had not occurred, it is apparent that MWH seriously and egregiously breached its fiduciary responsibility to protect the citizens of Los Osos from any and all actions that could potentially or reasonably be expected to do so.

It is worth noting that MWH and one of the three contractors (Barnard Construction) also donated $10,000 each to the campaign committee called “Save the Dream” to fight against the recall election, in a further effort to influence the outcome of the vote – both would have benefited financially if the recall had not been successful.

The contractors invoiced the District for $1.616M on August 24, 2005, two days after the August 22 formal NTP was issued; and MWH immediately approved the invoices the same day, without MWH performing their contractually required review of the invoices. MWH, working in cooperation with the former General Manager, then rushed the payment through. MWH blatantly ignored the contract requirements that all invoices are due and payable no earlier than 30 days after invoice approval. The contract documents and daily logs clearly show that the first payment clearly should have been due for payment on October 27, 2005. All of these expedited actions were done prior to the recall election held on 9/27/2005 and were intended to make termination of the project extremely costly and difficult. MWH would have benefited financially if termination of the project had not occurred. MWH’s rush to get those payments through solely benefited the contractors, was grievous to the District’s financial security, violated numerous contractual protections and was solely designed to influence the outcome of the pending recall election.

MWH was the only District consultant with the necessary technical expertise to assess the merits of the various technical issues that arose on the project. The District relied on MWH’s professional advice and representations that they were the subject matter expert on all aspects of the project. The District morally and contractually expected MWH to act in District’s best interest. As such, it is obvious that MWH has egregiously failed in their fiduciary obligation to represent the best interest of the District and the Citizens of Los Osos.

It is the District’s contention that MWH had a clear conflict of interest when they made recommendations or took actions which they knew or should have even minimally known were in clear violation of contract provisions, their fiduciary responsibility and State and Federal statutes. Most of all, MWH’s actions were patently not in the best interest of their “client”. MWH’s actions and repeated disregard for their client’s best interest were knowingly and willingly designed to expedite the award of the controversial construction contracts in advance of the recall election. It was in MWH’s financial interest to see the project go forward, but it clearly was to the absolute detriment of the District and the Citizens of Los Osos.

We strongly request that you investigate MWH’s actions in the matter. Our staff has voluminous additional proof of MWH’s shameful actions and ethics violations (correspondence, emails, board meeting tapes and minutes). I am available for additional questions at any time.


Sincerely,



Lisa Schicker, President
Board of Directors
Los Osos Community Services District

Sunday, May 14, 2006

Ron Crawford's Yin & Yang over at www.sewerwatch.blogspot.com. Cause & effect, truth & consequences, Dreamies & Realities. If you ever wanted to know what some of your neighbors thought of you and moved heaven and earth to attempt to get, just for you, their dear and gentle fellow Los Ososians, do take a gander at the nice selection of crunch and bite that Ron's assembled for you. Selected readings for your contemplation. Bon appetite!